Tariff change brokers provide prohibited legal advice – but not always!

– When is liability for damages and reimbursement of remuneration regularly incurred ? – The Regional Court (LG) Saarbrücken decided in its judgement of 17.05.2016 (Az. 14 O 152/15) that the search for savings possibilities with existing private health insurance (PKV) is not directed at the proof or mediation of an insurance contract, § 204 […]

BGH – Liability of tariff change optimizers also applies to old cases

Health insurers may demand an exclusion of benefits in the target tariff if the policyholder changes tariffs. The policyholder does not need to have an increased risk for this. This is clear from a ruling of the Federal Court of Justice (BGH). As a result, tariff change optimizers who accept unreasonably high risk surcharges for […]

Guarantees a use of comparison calculators by brokers…….

Does the use of comparison calculators by brokers guarantee that the advice is based on a ‘sufficient number of insurance contracts offered on the market and of insurers’ as required by § 60 VVG?   At this point, lawyer Dr. Johannes Fiala, lecturer for insurance law at the DHBW Heidenheim, will answer your questions. You […]

The tariff change according to § 204 VVG – (not) a typical broker task!

How insurance brokers deprive themselves of their remuneration through incorrectly designed sample contracts “It’s not the fall that kills you – it’s the sudden stop at the end.” (Douglas Adams) By judgment of 01.06.2012, the District Court of Schwäbisch Hall ordered an insurance broker to repay the remuneration for brokering a change of tariff. This […]

Court prohibits making it more difficult to change private health insurance tariffs by means of a “tariff structure surcharge

Premium adjustment clause of Allianz Krankenversicherung also invalid?   Penalisation of old customers as tariff switchers through premium surcharge Since the introduction of the new Aktimed tariffs, Allianz has levied an additional flat-rate surcharge, the so-called tariff structure surcharge, on all switchers from the old tariffs. This reduced the potential savings of those switching from […]

Insurance Law

Insurance law: inform in good time Nowadays, there is almost no aspect of life that cannot be covered by a insurance. The field of insurance law is broadly diversified and applies both in the area of private provision and in corporate risk minimization. Many insurances are almost regarded as basic equipment for a “carefree” life. […]

Cologne Higher Regional Court: Premium adjustments in private health insurance often ineffective!

– OLG Cologne judges generally usual procedure of the PKV as inadmissible –   In its judgment of 20 July 2012 (Case No.: 20 U 149/11), the Cologne Higher Regional Court ruled that a procedure used for decades by private health insurers for premium adjustments was incorrect. As a result, many premium adjustments since 1995 […]

Re-insurance by financial brokers and insurance brokers often without information about disadvantages

– When substitution of investments and insurance leads straight to liability –   By judgment of 24.07.2015, the OLG Cologne (Case No. 20 U 44/15) ruled that termination and sale of life insurance policies is typically associated with significant disadvantages. Since every insurance broker knows this, he has to point out the disadvantages. If the […]

Books / Technical articles

Publications – Technical papers Fiala/Schramm, Insolvency risk of British life insurers when relocating to Ireland, ExpertenReport, issue 7/2019, pages 60-62 Fiala/Schramm, When are insurers no longer obliged to pay benefits or can reduce benefits?Expert Report, issue 3/2019, pages 56-58 Fiala/Schramm, No insurance coverage in case of refusal to pay protection money, ExpertenReport, issue 11/2018. Pages […]

Federal Court of Justice: Insurance brokers do not have to look after customers on a permanent basis

– Why a broker is allowed to give advice on changing tariffs for a contingency fee –   The Federal Court of Justice decided (BGH, ruling of 28.06.2018, file no. I ZR 77/17) that an insurance brokerage contract does not require that the client is to be looked after on a permanent basis according to […]