Anyone emigrating tends to think first of health insurance, taxes, and registration obligations – statutory pension insurance is frequently overlooked in the process. This is risky in two respects: during the accrual phase, it can remain unclear whether and how pension entitlements can be continued at all while living abroad. And when the pension is later drawn, it often only becomes apparent that not every destination country is treated the same way – within the EU, the German pension is generally paid out in full without reduction, whereas in a country with no social security agreement, individual pension components may be excluded. This article explains what applies to the contribution obligation upon emigration, how already-acquired entitlements are affected by emigration, how the export of pensions abroad works, and which steps are advisable before departure.
Why the Insurance Obligation Ends Upon Emigration
The foundation of German social insurance is the territoriality principle under Section 3 of the German Social Code, Book Four (Sozialgesetzbuch IV, or SGB IV – the book of the Code that sets out the general provisions applicable to all branches of social insurance): the provisions on compulsory insurance apply to all persons who are employed or self-employed within the territorial scope of the Social Code. Anyone who leaves this territorial scope upon emigration and takes up employment or self-employment abroad thereby generally falls outside German compulsory insurance – regardless of whether comparable coverage exists in the destination country.
An exception applies under the so-called “Ausstrahlung” (radiating effect) rule in Section 4 SGB IV: if a person is posted abroad for a limited period by a domestic employer within the framework of a continuing employment relationship, German compulsory insurance continues to apply during the posting. However, this provision specifically covers fixed-term postings, not permanent emigration with a new center of life abroad – anyone who gives up their job in Germany and reorients themselves professionally in the destination country cannot rely on this provision.
Contribution Obligation During the Accrual Phase: Two Ways to Continue Coverage
If compulsory insurance ends upon emigration, this does not necessarily mean that pension entitlements can no longer grow while abroad. The German Social Code, Book Six (Sozialgesetzbuch VI, or SGB VI – the book of the Code governing statutory pension insurance), provides for two different instruments that differ considerably in their target group and requirements.
Voluntary Continued Insurance Under Section 7 SGB VI
Under Section 7(1) SGB VI, persons who are not subject to compulsory insurance may voluntarily insure themselves from the completion of their 16th year of life – the statutory text expressly clarifies that this also applies to German nationals who have their habitual residence abroad. Unlike with statutory health insurance, there is therefore no restriction here to EU or treaty countries: voluntary insurance is generally open worldwide, regardless of the destination country of emigration.
Voluntary insurance is excluded under Section 7(2) SGB VI only once a full old-age pension has been bindingly awarded and the month in which the standard retirement age was reached has elapsed – for emigrants of working age, this restriction is generally irrelevant.
In practice, this means that anyone who is not subject to compulsory insurance abroad, or who wishes to continue building up their German pension entitlement in parallel, can do so through voluntary contributions. The amount of the contributions can be freely chosen within the statutory minimum and maximum limits, which opens up scope for structuring but also means that, without active steps, no further earnings points (Entgeltpunkte – the units used to calculate the amount of a German statutory pension) will simply accrue.
Compulsory Insurance Upon Application for the Self-Employed Under Section 4(2) SGB VI
Anyone who becomes self-employed abroad and wants coverage that is closer to compulsory insurance rather than merely voluntary insurance can alternatively make use of compulsory insurance upon application under Section 4(2) SGB VI. It is open to persons who are self-employed on more than a merely temporary basis, provided the application is filed within five years of taking up the self-employed activity. If this deadline is missed, access to compulsory insurance upon application for that activity is permanently closed – a later application is then no longer possible.
The practical difference from voluntary insurance lies chiefly in the fact that compulsory insurance upon application establishes genuine compulsory membership, which generally cannot be unilaterally terminated but ends only under the statutory conditions – for example, upon giving up the self-employed activity. Anyone who opts for this route therefore commits more strongly than under voluntary insurance, but in return also secures benefits that may be linked to compulsory membership.
Deadlines for Contribution Payments
Regardless of which route is chosen, Section 197 SGB VI sets a fixed payment deadline for voluntary contributions: they are only effective if paid by 31 March of the year following the contribution year. The law permits a later payment after this deadline has expired only in narrow cases of hardship – for example, if payment was prevented through no fault of the insured person’s own and the application is filed within three months of the obstacle ceasing to exist. Anyone living abroad who loses sight of these deadlines therefore risks not only a gap in their insurance record but simply the irretrievable loss of contribution periods that were paid but reported late.
What Happens to Pension Entitlements Already Acquired?
Unlike some forms of company or private retirement provision, a key advantage of statutory pension insurance is that entitlements once acquired do not automatically lapse upon emigration abroad. The contribution periods, earnings points, and qualifying periods (Wartezeiten – the minimum insurance periods required before a pension claim arises) recorded in the insurance record generally remain intact – emigration itself is not an event that extinguishes already-acquired entitlements.
What does change upon emigration, however, is the question of how and to what extent these entitlements are actually paid out later. This is precisely where pension export comes in: it does not govern whether an entitlement exists, but whether and to what extent it is also paid out where the recipient is resident outside Germany.
Pension Export Abroad: EU/EEA, Treaty States, and Non-Treaty Countries
Section 110 SGB VI forms the basis for the payment of pensions abroad. Under this provision, beneficiaries who are only temporarily staying abroad receive their benefits in the same way as beneficiaries with their habitual residence in Germany (Section 110(1) SGB VI). Where there is a permanent residence abroad, however, the special provisions of the section on benefits to beneficiaries abroad apply – and these, in turn, are subject to supranational or international law (Section 110(3) SGB VI), meaning in particular EU law and bilateral social security agreements.
The practical amount of the exported pension is determined chiefly by the provisions on calculating personal earnings points under Sections 113 and 114 SGB VI: for beneficiaries with their habitual residence abroad, personal earnings points are generally calculated only from so-called “Bundesgebiets-Beitragszeiten” (federal territory contribution periods) – that is, from contribution periods for which contributions were paid under federal law after 8 May 1945. According to the Deutsche Rentenversicherung’s own information, certain pension components – for instance those arising from so-called “Reichsgebiets-Beitragszeiten” (contribution periods completed in the former territory of the German Reich) or from periods under the Fremdrentengesetz (Foreign Pension Act, which governs the recognition of insurance periods completed outside the current territory of the Federal Republic, in particular by ethnic German resettlers and displaced persons) – are generally not paid abroad where the beneficiary resides outside the EU/EEA states and Switzerland. In practice, this restriction chiefly affects older insurance biographies connected to the former eastern German territories or to periods as an expellee or ethnic German resettler; it generally plays no role for purely West German or EU-based employment biographies.
In addition, there is a special constellation for pensions due to reduced earning capacity: where the pension is based not only on medical grounds but also on the fact that the labor market is closed to the person concerned, restrictions on payment may arise where the recipient is resident outside Germany, since this labor-market-related component is tied to conditions on the German labor market.
In practice, three case groups can be distinguished, which differ considerably in their effect on pension export:
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Destination Country Category | Legal Basis | Effect on Pension Export |
|---|---|---|
| EU/EEA states and Switzerland | EU law on the coordination of social security systems, Section 110(3) SGB VI | Pension is generally paid in full, as for residence in Germany, including all earnings points |
| Treaty states (e.g., the USA, Canada, Australia, Japan, Turkey, Israel, Brazil, and others) | Bilateral social security agreement, Section 110(3) SGB VI | Payment and aggregation of insurance periods according to the rules of the respective agreement; scope can vary depending on the agreement |
| Genuine non-treaty third country (no agreement, no EU/EEA membership) | Section 110(2), Sections 113, 114 SGB VI | Pension components based on federal territory contribution periods generally continue to be paid; components from Reich territory contribution periods or periods under the Foreign Pension Act, as well as foreign insurance periods that cannot be credited, are generally disregarded |
According to the Deutsche Rentenversicherung’s own information, Germany currently has bilateral social security agreements with 21 states outside the EU/EEA and Switzerland, including the USA, Canada, Australia, Japan, Turkey, Israel, Brazil, India, South Korea, Tunisia, Morocco, and several Balkan states. In addition, a separate posted-workers agreement with the People’s Republic of China has been in place since 2002 – however, this is not a complete social security agreement but solely provides that posted employees do not have to pay double contributions to pension and unemployment insurance; it contains no provisions on the acquisition or payment of pension entitlements. It should also be noted that not all of the 21 full agreements have the same scope – individual agreements, for instance with Morocco, Tunisia, and Turkey, contain content-related limitations compared with the otherwise usual treaty standard. Anyone emigrating to a treaty state should therefore not assume across the board that treatment will be equivalent to that within the EU, but should have the specific agreement and its scope examined.
Jurisdiction: No Central Authority, but Staggered Responsibility Among Insurance Carriers
Contrary to what the term “Auslandsrentenstelle” (foreign pension office) might suggest, there is no single, central authority responsible for all emigrants. According to the Deutsche Rentenversicherung, responsibility always lies with the carrier to which contributions in Germany were most recently paid: this may be the Deutsche Rentenversicherung Bund, the Deutsche Rentenversicherung Knappschaft-Bahn-See – as soon as contributions have flowed there at any point – or one of the 14 regional carriers, whose jurisdiction is determined by the last place of employment or residence. These two nationally responsible carriers, together with the 14 regional carriers, make up the 16 carriers of statutory pension insurance in Germany. Anyone living abroad who contacts the “wrong” office does not thereby lose any entitlements, but processing is delayed because the matter first has to be forwarded to the correct carrier. Before making contact, it is therefore worthwhile clarifying, based on one’s own insurance number or the most recent contribution payment, which carrier is actually responsible.
Reconciling the Insurance Account Before Emigration
A step frequently underestimated in practice is account reconciliation (“Kontenklärung”) – reviewing and completing one’s own insurance record – before departure. As long as a person still lives in Germany, missing evidence of education, employment, or child-raising periods can generally be supplied considerably more easily than from abroad, where contact with former employers, schools, or authorities can be more difficult. The Deutsche Rentenversicherung offers its own application procedure for account reconciliation, which can be initiated online or in writing and serves to reconcile the recorded insurance record with one’s own documents and to close any gaps.
Anyone who already has prior periods of employment abroad should also disclose these as part of the account reconciliation, since, depending on EU law, a social security agreement, or the law on foreign pensions, they may become relevant to the later pension calculation. After emigration, it is also advisable to notify the pension insurance provider of the new foreign address and bank details in good time – the Deutsche Rentenversicherung recommends a lead time of around two months before a later pension commencement or a move while already drawing a pension – in order to avoid later interruptions to payment.
Hypothetical Example for Illustration
The following example is entirely fictional and is intended solely for illustration; it does not describe any real case or any real person. A 42-year-old engineer with a complete German employment biography gives up his permanent position and emigrates to Vietnam to work there as a self-employed consultant. Since Vietnam is neither an EU/EEA state nor a treaty state, his compulsory insurance ends on his last day of German employment. He opts for voluntary insurance under Section 7(1) SGB VI in order to continue building up his pension entitlement, and pays the contributions on time before 31 March of the following year in each case. Since his entire employment biography to date is based on federal territory contribution periods, his later pension remains practically unaffected by the restricted pension export to non-treaty states – the position would be different had his insurance record still contained entitlements from the Foreign Pension Act or from Reich territory contribution periods.
When Is Legal Advice Worthwhile?
Legal advice is particularly worthwhile where a person’s own insurance biography is not straightforward – for example, in the case of a mix of German, other-EU, and third-country contribution periods, prior periods of employment under the Foreign Pension Act, or planned emigration to a country whose social security agreement with Germany has only limited scope. Anyone weighing up voluntary insurance against compulsory insurance upon application as a self-employed person likewise benefits from a case-by-case assessment, since the five-year application deadline under Section 4(2) SGB VI can elapse irretrievably. Not least, advice can be worthwhile where a pension notice with a reduced foreign component has already been issued and it needs to be examined whether the classification of contribution periods on which it is based is correct.
Conclusion
Statutory pension insurance does not end upon emigration, but its legal framework changes: compulsory insurance regularly lapses upon leaving the German territorial scope, but can be continued through voluntary insurance under Section 7 SGB VI or – for self-employed persons, within five years – through compulsory insurance upon application under Section 4(2) SGB VI. Entitlements already acquired are not lost through emigration, but their later payment depends on the destination country: within the EU, the EEA, and Switzerland, pension export generally occurs without reduction; in treaty states, it occurs in accordance with the respective agreement; and in genuine non-treaty countries, individual pension components not based on federal territory contribution periods may go unpaid under Sections 113 and 114 SGB VI. Anyone who is aware of these key decisions early, has their insurance record clarified before emigrating, and keeps an eye on deadlines such as account reconciliation and the payment deadline under Section 197 SGB VI, secures the foundation for reliable retirement provision – regardless of where the path abroad leads.
The Fiala law firm has published extensively on international social security law and assists clients in structuring their contribution obligations under statutory pension insurance in a legally sound manner upon emigration, and in clarifying the later export of their pension at an early stage – particularly in the case of complex or mixed insurance biographies. If you have questions about your individual situation, please feel free to contact the firm on a non-binding basis.
