Criminal Liability for Delayed Insolvency Filing by a Foreign Company: Section 15a InsO Explained

Criminal Liability for Delayed Insolvency Filing by a Foreign Company: Section 15a InsO Explained

Delayed Insolvency Filing: Foreign Companies

Anyone who runs a company incorporated abroad from Germany often underestimates one risk: criminal liability for delayed insolvency filing (Insolvenzverschleppung) at a foreign company is governed not by the state of incorporation but, in many cases, by German law. Since the MoMiG (Act to Modernise the Law on Limited Liability Companies) entered into force on 1 November 2008, the duty to file for insolvency in Section 15a of the Insolvency Code (Insolvenzordnung, InsO) has been drafted neutrally as to legal form. The legislator wanted precisely to prevent the managers of a limited company from an EU state, an Ltd. & Co. KG or another foreign legal form from evading the German filing duty. What matters is where the company has the centre of its main interests. If it is in Germany, a director who files late faces imprisonment of up to three years or a fine and, after a conviction for an intentional offence, also a five-year ban from serving as a managing director.

The civil-law liability of the officers of an insolvent foreign subsidiary is covered in detail in the article Managing director liability for an insolvent foreign subsidiary; this article is about criminal law.

What Delayed Insolvency Filing Means Under Criminal Law

Delayed insolvency filing is not an offence of the Criminal Code (Strafgesetzbuch, StGB) but is found in the Insolvency Code itself. Section 15a (1) sentence 1 InsO obliges the members of the representative body or the liquidators of a legal entity to file an application to open proceedings without culpable delay in case of illiquidity or over-indebtedness. Section 15a (4) InsO punishes anyone who does not file this application, or does not file it in time (no. 1), or does not file it correctly (no. 2). It is a genuine offence of omission: the failure to act despite a duty is punishable, and damage to creditors does not have to be proven.

Range of Penalties at a Glance

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Form of commission Provision Range of penalty Limitation
Intentional, application not filed or not filed in time Section 15a (4) no. 1 InsO imprisonment up to 3 years or fine 5 years (Section 78 (3) no. 4 StGB)
Intentional, application not filed correctly Section 15a (4) no. 2, (6) InsO as above, but only if finally rejected as inadmissible 5 years
Negligent Section 15a (5) InsO imprisonment up to 1 year or fine 3 years (Section 78 (3) no. 5 StGB)

Conditional intent (bedingter Vorsatz) is sufficient. It is likely where the manager considers insolvency possible and carries on anyway. A person acts negligently who, with due care, should have recognised the crisis, for example because they did not monitor the accounts and liquidity planning for months. Limitation begins only on completion of the offence, that is, in principle when the filing duty lapses, for example because an application was filed or the crisis was overcome.

When a Foreign Company Falls Under Section 15a InsO

Filing Duty Neutral as to Legal Form

Section 15a (1) sentence 1 InsO speaks generally of a “legal entity” without referring to German legal forms. According to the explanatory memorandum to the MoMiG, this was expressly meant to cover foreign companies that carry on their activity predominantly or exclusively in Germany, the so-called pseudo-foreign companies (Scheinauslandsgesellschaften). Typical is the limited company incorporated in England whose director lives in Germany and whose entire business takes place here; there are similar set-ups with companies from Ireland, Malta, Cyprus or the Netherlands.

By its wording, the duty would be unlimited. The prevailing view in the literature therefore restricts it: the German filing duty applies to a foreign company only if the centre of its main interests is in Germany and German main insolvency proceedings are therefore possible. For a company represented in Germany only by a branch whose actual management sits abroad, the insolvency law of the other state generally applies.

Article 3 and Article 7 EU Insolvency Regulation: The Centre of Interests Decides

For companies from EU member states (except Denmark), the European Insolvency Regulation (EU) 2015/848 (EuInsVO) applies. Under Article 3 (1) EuInsVO, the courts of the member state in whose territory the debtor has the centre of its main interests (COMI) have jurisdiction for the main insolvency proceedings. For companies, it is rebuttably presumed that this centre is at the registered office. The presumption is rebutted if management actually takes place from another state, in a way recognisable to third parties.

Under Article 7 EuInsVO, the law of the state of opening applies to the proceedings and their effects. In the Kornhaas case (judgment of 10 December 2015, C-594/14), the European Court of Justice held that the then liability provision of Section 64 of the Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG) may be applied against the director of a limited company registered in Cardiff over whose assets insolvency proceedings had been opened in Germany. It saw no impermissible restriction of the freedom of establishment in this. The decision concerned civil-law reimbursement liability, but also supports the classification of the filing duty as insolvency law.

Whether the penal provision of Section 15a (4) InsO is to be applied without restriction to the officers of EU foreign companies is discussed in the literature from the angle of the requirement of certainty; no supreme-court decision on the director of a foreign company has been published. The Berlin Higher Regional Court (Kammergericht) has, however, denied the criminal liability of a shareholder under Section 15a (3) InsO at an English limited company (see below on lack of management). It has decided nothing on Section 15a (1) InsO, and with Section 15a (1) InsO the legislator also wanted to cover foreign companies with their administrative seat in Germany (Bundestag document 16/6140, p. 55). Nobody should rely on this: if the centre of interests is in Germany, investigations are to be expected.

Partnerships With a Foreign General Partner

Section 15a (1) sentence 3 InsO extends the duty to partnerships with legal capacity in which no personally liable partner is a natural person. This concerns the formerly widespread Ltd. & Co. KG: the statutory representatives of the general partner, that is, the director of the limited company, are then subject to the filing duty. Section 15a (2) InsO extends this to multi-tier structures. The penalty of paragraph 4 applies to these persons as well.

Special Case: The English Limited After Brexit

Since the end of the transition period on 31 December 2020, the United Kingdom has been a third country. The EuInsVO no longer applies in relation to it for new proceedings, and an English limited company can no longer rely on the freedom of establishment; the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof) confirmed this in February 2021 (II ZB 25/17). The law at the actual administrative seat (seat theory, Sitztheorie) is therefore decisive again.

Under the so-called modified seat theory that the Federal Court of Justice developed for third-country companies (judgment of 27 October 2008, II ZR 158/06, “Trabrennbahn”), such a company is not treated as a legal nullity but, depending on its structure, as a civil-law partnership (GbR), a general commercial partnership (OHG) or, with only one shareholder, as a sole proprietorship. The shareholders are then personally liable without limit. A limited company run from Germany therefore all the more does not offer the hoped-for limitation of liability; see also the article The cheap trap of the English limited company.

For criminal law, this results in a shift that many of those affected do not know:

  • If all shareholders are natural persons, the company is, from the German point of view, a partnership with natural persons liable without limit. A filing duty under Section 15a InsO then in principle does not exist, because the provision covers only legal entities and partnerships without a natural person liable without limit.
  • If, on the other hand, a shareholder is itself a corporation, Section 15a (1) sentence 3 InsO can apply, and the manager of this shareholder becomes subject to the filing duty.
  • Irrespective of this, the bankruptcy offences of Sections 283 et seq. StGB and the withholding of employment remuneration under Section 266a StGB remain applicable.

For acts completed before 1 January 2021, the legal position at that time applies. How the change of status affects a crisis that lasted beyond the turn of the year 2020/2021 must be examined in the individual case. Anyone who still has a limited company run from Germany today should not postpone restructuring any further; notes on relocating the seat and management are given in the article Relocating a GmbH seat abroad.

Companies from other third countries are likewise in principle treated under the seat theory. According to the prevailing view, an exception applies to companies from the USA, because the German-American Treaty of Friendship, Commerce and Navigation of 1954 provides for recognition under the law of incorporation. Whether and how Section 15a InsO applies to a US company run from Germany should be examined in the individual case; an adviser on the ground there should be consulted on the law of the state of incorporation.

The Deadlines: Three Weeks and Six Weeks

Since the Act on the Further Development of Restructuring and Insolvency Law (SanInsFoG), in force since 1 January 2021, Section 15a (1) sentence 2 InsO distinguishes two maximum periods:

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Ground for insolvency Definition Maximum period
Illiquidity (Section 17 InsO) Due payment obligations cannot be met; according to case law regularly where there is a funding gap of 10% or more that cannot be closed within three weeks 3 weeks
Over-indebtedness (Section 19 InsO) Assets do not cover the liabilities, and continuation over the next twelve months is not predominantly likely 6 weeks

Both periods are maximum periods. What matters first is the requirement to file the application “without culpable delay”. The period may be used up only as long as serious and promising restructuring efforts are under way. If a restructuring has evidently failed, the application must be filed immediately. According to the prevailing view, the period begins with the objective occurrence of insolvency; subjective awareness matters only for the question of whether there is intent or negligence. Until the end of 2020, a maximum period of three weeks also applied to over-indebtedness.

The pandemic-related suspensions under the COVInsAG and the temporary shortening of the forecast period by the SanInsKG have expired; in 2026 the regular periods apply.

Who Can Be the Offender

Director, Managing Director, Liquidator

The members of the representative body are subject to the filing duty. For a limited company this is the director; where there are several directors, each one individually. An internal allocation of responsibilities relieves only to a limited extent; each must monitor the economic situation and ask questions at signs of a crisis. The duty also applies to liquidators of a dissolved company.

Anyone who resigns their office after insolvency has occurred remains criminally responsible for the period until they leave.

De Facto Managing Director

A person who is not formally appointed at all but in fact runs the company can also be punishable. The Federal Court of Justice has confirmed that a de facto managing director can be the offender of delayed insolvency filing under Section 15a (4) InsO and that the MoMiG changed nothing about this (decision of 18 December 2014, 4 StR 323/14). The registered managing director was convicted of aiding and abetting in those proceedings.

With foreign companies this constellation is frequent: a straw man is entered in the foreign register as director, while the actual decisions are made by a person behind the scenes living in Germany. Both then bear a risk of criminal liability, the person behind the scenes as de facto manager, the registered director as offender or accessory. A nominee structure registered abroad therefore does not protect.

Shareholders in Case of Lack of Management

If a GmbH has no management (Führungslosigkeit), every shareholder is subject to the filing duty under Section 15a (3) InsO if they know of the insolvency and the lack of management; for a stock corporation (AG) and a cooperative, the duty falls on the supervisory board. For criminal liability, the Berlin Higher Regional Court has held that Section 15a (3) InsO is not applicable to an English limited company: the provision names only the GmbH, AG and cooperative, and an extension to comparable foreign companies would exceed the limit of the wording (KG Berlin, decision of 10 August 2022, 4 Ss 115/22 et al.). The court left open whether Section 15a (1) InsO is to be applied to foreign companies with a domestic administrative seat. According to this decision, shareholders of an English limited company are therefore not subject to the filing duty and not punishable under Section 15a (4) InsO in case of lack of management.

An Application “Not Filed Correctly”

Anyone who files an application in time is not automatically on the safe side. Section 15a (4) no. 2 InsO also covers an application not filed correctly, that is, an application with missing or false mandatory information under Section 13 (1) InsO, for example without a complete list of creditors. Under Section 15a (6) InsO, however, this variant is punishable only if the application has been finally rejected as inadmissible. If the applicant remedies the defects within the period set by the court, he remains unpunished in this respect.

With foreign companies an additional question arises: is an application to the court of the state of incorporation sufficient if the centre of interests is in truth in Germany? Under Article 3 EuInsVO, the court at the centre of interests has jurisdiction for the main proceedings. An application to a court without jurisdiction can therefore be risky. In case of doubt, the application should be filed in the state in which the centre of interests lies according to the objective circumstances, and the grounds should set out the jurisdiction comprehensibly.

Residence Abroad Does Not Protect From Prosecution

Under Section 9 (1) StGB, an offence is also committed at the place where, in the case of omission, the offender should have acted. If the German insolvency court has jurisdiction, the place of the offence is in Germany, and German criminal law applies under Section 3 StGB, even if the director lives in Spain, Dubai or Thailand.

The same applies to managing directors of a German GmbH who have moved abroad. Which other duties continue after a move is covered in the article Managing director emigration and liability. If an accused living abroad is investigated, an arrest warrant, a notice for arrest and, within the EU, a European Arrest Warrant come into consideration. Whether and under what conditions the state of residence extradites depends on its law and on the applicable treaties; an adviser on the ground there should be consulted on this. In addition, a relocated place of management can also trigger tax consequences, which the article Relocating the company seat abroad explains.

How Proceedings Get Started

Delayed insolvency filing is an offence prosecuted ex officio. Under the orders on notifications in civil matters (MiZi), insolvency courts notify the public prosecutor’s office of the opening of proceedings and of dismissal for lack of assets; the public prosecutor’s office then examines an initial suspicion of its own motion. Further triggers are criminal complaints by creditors, tips from health insurance funds and the insolvency administrator’s report on when insolvency occurred.

With foreign companies there is something further: a relocation of the seat shortly before the crisis is viewed critically under Article 3 (1) subparagraph 2 EuInsVO. If the registered office was relocated in the three months before the application, the presumption in favour of the registered office does not apply.

Consequences Beyond the Penalty

Ban From Serving as Managing Director

Anyone finally convicted of intentional delayed insolvency filing cannot, under Section 6 (2) sentence 2 no. 3 letter a GmbHG, be a managing director of a GmbH for five years from the conviction becoming final; a corresponding rule applies to management board members of an AG under the Stock Corporation Act. Under Section 6 (2) sentence 3 GmbHG, this also applies to a conviction abroad for a comparable offence. A conviction for negligent commission alone does not trigger this ban. Under trade law, a conviction can also give rise to doubts about reliability.

Civil-Law Liability

Criminal liability and civil-law liability run in parallel. Section 15a InsO is a protective statute within the meaning of Section 823 (2) of the Civil Code (BGB); old creditors can claim the quota damage, new creditors, according to case law, their full reliance damage. In addition there is the reimbursement duty for payments after insolvency under Section 15b InsO, which since 2021 has replaced Section 64 GmbHG. This liability often weighs more heavily economically than the penalty. A German judgment can also be enforced abroad; on this see the article Enforcement of German judgments abroad.

Accompanying Offences in Brief

Alongside Section 15a InsO, investigators regularly examine bankruptcy (Section 283 StGB), for example by diverting assets or defective bookkeeping in the crisis, breach of the duty to keep accounts (Section 283b StGB), favouring of creditors (Section 283c StGB), withholding of employment remuneration (Section 266a StGB) and fraud on entering into a transaction (Section 263 StGB). These offences presuppose active conduct or further breaches of duty and can be committed alongside delayed insolvency filing. For officers of foreign companies, Section 14 StGB conveys responsibility for duties that actually fall on the company.

Practical Mistakes With Foreign Companies

Typical mistakes in investigation proceedings:

  1. Assuming only the law of incorporation applies. Anyone who runs an EU company from Germany is regularly subject to Section 15a InsO in a crisis.
  2. Missing liquidity planning. Without it, it cannot be shown when the crisis occurred; this makes the negligence allegation easier.
  3. Straw-man director abroad. Actual management from Germany makes the person behind the scenes the de facto manager.
  4. Application in the wrong state. An application to a court without jurisdiction can let the period pass unused.
  5. Relocation of the seat in the crisis. It is examined by the courts with particular care and can create additional avoidance and bankruptcy risks.

Example

Martin, a fictitious entrepreneur from Augsburg, is the sole director of a limited company registered in Ireland. The company has only a postal address in Ireland; customers, employees, office and bank account are in Bavaria. In March 2026, the company can no longer pay due invoices of EUR 180,000; EUR 40,000 is available. Martin hopes for a large order and does not file an application until August. Because the centre of interests is in Germany, the German insolvency court has jurisdiction, and Section 15a InsO applies. The three-week period had expired in April. Martin faces proceedings for intentional delayed insolvency filing, plus reimbursement of the payments made after insolvency.

Conclusion

Criminal liability for delayed insolvency filing at a foreign company does not depend on the place of incorporation but on the centre of main interests. If it is in Germany, Section 15a InsO applies with its periods of three weeks for illiquidity and six weeks for over-indebtedness, and the penalty of Section 15a (4) and (5) InsO affects the director, the de facto manager and, in multi-tier structures, also the officers of the general partner. Residence abroad changes nothing about this. Since Brexit, the English limited company run from Germany is, from the German point of view, usually a partnership with personal liability of the shareholders.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does Section 15a InsO also apply to a limited company with its seat abroad?

Yes, for a company from another EU state (such as Ireland or the Netherlands) if it has its centre of main interests in Germany. The filing duty has been drafted neutrally as to legal form since 2008 and is meant precisely to cover pseudo-foreign companies. For an English limited company, something different has applied since Brexit: it can no longer rely on the freedom of establishment (BGH, decision of 16 February 2021, II ZB 25/17) and, if run from here, is treated from the German point of view not as a legal entity but, depending on the group of shareholders, as a GbR, OHG or sole proprietorship (so the principles on the seat theory for third-country companies in BGH, judgment of 27 October 2008, II ZR 158/06, Trabrennbahn). Section 15a InsO then applies only if no shareholder is a natural person.

What penalty does the director of a foreign company face?

For intentional delayed insolvency filing, imprisonment of up to three years or a fine; for negligent commission, imprisonment of up to one year or a fine. After a conviction for an intentional offence, a five-year ban from serving as a GmbH managing director follows.

Does a residence abroad protect me from criminal proceedings in Germany?

No, as a rule not. With an offence of omission, the place of the offence is where the application should have been filed. If the German insolvency court has jurisdiction, German criminal law applies. Whether the state of residence extradites is to be clarified with an adviser on the ground there.

As a merely registered director, can I rely on the person behind the scenes?

Only to a limited extent. The registered director remains an officer and must monitor the situation. The person behind the scenes who actually runs the company can additionally be punishable as de facto managing director; the Federal Court of Justice has expressly confirmed this for the GmbH.

When does delayed insolvency filing become time-barred?

The intentional offence is time-barred after five years, the negligent one after three years. The period begins only on completion of the offence, that is, in principle when the filing duty lapses.

Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm, with a focus on international inheritance law, tax law and asset protection in Munich, advise entrepreneurs and managers of foreign companies on questions of the insolvency filing duty with a foreign element, from determining the centre of interests and crisis precautions to liability and criminal-liability risks. Dr. Fiala has published extensively on emigration and asset protection. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.

Do you have questions?

Please do not hesitate to call us for an introductory conversation. I will gladly take the time personally to review your case and give you an estimate of the work involved.

That way, you will already be one step further!

You can reach us by phone at +49 89 / 17 90 900 or by clicking the button:

Call now
Portrait Dr. Fiala

Dr. Johannes Fiala

Your lawyer in Munich is reliable and competent, always by your side.

Recommend us

Found what you were looking for? Do you know someone who could use our support? Feel free to recommend us.