Anyone who gives gifts during their lifetime often hears the rule of thumb: wait 10 years, then everything is settled. In fact, for a gift there is not one single 10-year period but three different ten-year periods in three areas of law. Tax law aggregates gifts made within ten years (Section 14 of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act, ErbStG), compulsory share law lets gifts phase out over ten years (Section 2325 (3) of the German Civil Code, BGB), and in a nursing care case the donor, or in his or her place the social welfare office, can reclaim a gift if the donor becomes needy within ten years of the gift (Sections 528, 529 BGB). Each of these periods starts at a different point in time, and a reserved usufruct (Nießbrauch) affects each of them differently. The following overview shows which period runs when (as of 26 October 2026).
How gifts fit into succession planning as a whole is covered in the article Transfer of assets during lifetime instead of a will, also with a cross-border element; this article is about the periods themselves.
The Three Periods Compared
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Tax: aggregation | Compulsory share: supplement | Nursing care: reclaim | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Provision | Section 14 (1) ErbStG | Section 2325 (3) BGB | Sections 528, 529 (1) BGB, Section 93 of the Twelfth Book of the Social Code (SGB XII) |
| Who benefits | the tax office while the period runs; the recipient after it expires (new allowance) | persons entitled to a compulsory share, such as disinherited children | the impoverished donor, in case of social assistance the social assistance authority |
| Start of period | the period is counted backwards from the last acquisition | performance of the gift, for real property at the earliest registration in the land register | performance of the gift, for real property the application for registration after conveyance (Auflassung) suffices |
| Effect | earlier acquisitions are added to the last one, allowance only once | phase-out by one tenth per year, zero after ten years | fixed period without phase-out: fully within it, excluded afterwards |
| Reserved usufruct | does not change the running of the period | period does not start where the usufruct covers the whole object | period runs regardless |
| Spouses | no special rule on the running of the period | period does not start before the marriage is dissolved | no special rule |
A common error is to treat all three periods like the compulsory share period: a phase-out exists only for the compulsory share, not for tax and not for the social welfare office.
Period 1: Aggregation under Section 14 ErbStG and the Allowance for Gifts
What Is Aggregated
Under Section 14 (1) sentence 1 ErbStG, several benefits received from the same person within ten years are aggregated: the earlier acquisitions are added to the last one at their earlier value. From the tax on the total amount, the tax that would have been levied on the earlier acquisitions under current law is deducted, or the tax actually paid if that is higher (Section 14 (1) sentences 2 and 3 ErbStG). The tax for the last acquisition must not be lower than it would be without aggregation (sentence 4).
The allowance is thus available only once per donor and recipient in ten years; each parent has a separate one in relation to each child. Aggregation can also raise the tax rate. An inheritance is also an acquisition from the same person: if the donor dies within ten years, the gift is counted in on the death. After the ten years have expired, the allowance is again fully available. When a further gift through intermediaries is recognised is covered in the article on chain gifts and gift tax, also with a cross-border element. The idea of using allowances several times in a ten-year rhythm already appears in an older article by the firm from 2007; the amounts given there are outdated, and the following apply.
Allowances and Tax Classes
The personal allowances of Section 16 (1) ErbStG apply equally to gifts and inheritances under unlimited tax liability; the tax classes follow from Section 15 (1) ErbStG. Under limited tax liability, the allowance is reduced by a partial amount that depends on the share of assets not subject to limited tax liability in all acquisitions from the same person within ten years (Section 16 (2) ErbStG).
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Recipient (relationship to donor) | Tax class | Allowance |
|---|---|---|
| Spouse, registered life partner | I | 500,000 EUR |
| Children, stepchildren, children of deceased children | I | 400,000 EUR |
| Grandchildren (children of living children) | I | 200,000 EUR |
| Other persons in tax class I, such as great-grandchildren, parents on acquisition on death | I | 100,000 EUR |
| Parents and grandparents on gifts, siblings, nieces and nephews, stepparents, sons- and daughters-in-law, parents-in-law, divorced spouse | II | 20,000 EUR |
| All others, such as partners without marriage, friends | III | 20,000 EUR |
If a child gives something to his or her parents, therefore, only tax class II applies.
Tax Rates
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Taxable acquisition up to and including | Tax class I | Tax class II | Tax class III |
|---|---|---|---|
| 75,000 EUR | 7 % | 15 % | 30 % |
| 300,000 EUR | 11 % | 20 % | 30 % |
| 600,000 EUR | 15 % | 25 % | 30 % |
| 6,000,000 EUR | 19 % | 30 % | 30 % |
| 13,000,000 EUR | 23 % | 35 % | 50 % |
| 26,000,000 EUR | 27 % | 40 % | 50 % |
| over 26,000,000 EUR | 30 % | 43 % | 50 % |
Source: Section 19 (1) ErbStG; just above a value threshold, the hardship adjustment (Härteausgleich, Section 19 (3)) softens the jump. A compact overview of further tax structures is given in the article Avoiding inheritance tax legally; the firm’s topics around gift tax and inheritance tax are bundled on a page of their own.
Two proceedings on inheritance tax are pending before the Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht). The abstract judicial review brought by the Free State of Bavaria (1 BvF 1/23, oral hearing on 12 October 2026) is directed, among other things, against the personal allowances (Section 16 (1) ErbStG) and the tax rates (Section 19 (1) ErbStG). The constitutional complaint 1 BvR 804/22 (hearing on 13 October 2026) concerns the privileges for business assets. As of 9 November 2026, no decision has been issued in either proceeding. Until then, current law applies. Whether and how allowances and tax rates will be changed afterwards is open. Where the tax treatment of a larger gift is unclear, a binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) under Section 89 (2) of the Fiscal Code (AO) can be considered in advance.
How the Period Is Calculated
According to the Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof), the ten-year period is calculated backwards from the last acquisition; its day counts. Section 108 (3) AO, which extends periods ending on a weekend or public holiday, does not apply to it; what matters are full calendar days, not the time of day (BFH, judgment of 28.03.2012, II R 43/11). In the case decided, a gift of 31.12.1998 lay outside the period for a further gift of 31.12.2008.
A second gift on the same calendar day ten years later therefore no longer aggregates the first: for a gift on 30.06.2026, only the time from 01.07.2016 counts. What matters in each case is the execution of the transfer (Section 9 (1) no. 2 ErbStG). For real property, according to the Federal Fiscal Court, the gift is already executed when the conveyance (Auflassung) has been recorded and the donor has consented to the registration (BFH, II R 43/11, referring to II R 26/02). Because the time depends on the individual case, we recommend a buffer of a few weeks.
Calculation Example: Two Gifts Within Ten Years
Assumptions (fictitious): father Thomas gives his son Jonas securities worth 300,000 EUR in 2020 and a further 300,000 EUR in 2026.
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Step | Amount |
|---|---|
| Acquisition 2020: 300,000 EUR, less allowance 400,000 EUR: taxable 0 EUR, tax 2020 | 0 EUR |
| Aggregation of 2020 and 2026 | 600,000 EUR |
| less allowance (only once) | 400,000 EUR |
| taxable acquisition | 200,000 EUR |
| Tax 11 % (tax class I, up to 300,000 EUR) | 22,000 EUR |
| less tax on the earlier acquisition | 0 EUR |
| Tax 2026 | 22,000 EUR |
Variant: outside the ten years, or from the own assets of Jonas’s mother (own allowance of 400,000 EUR), the second gift would also remain tax-free.
Usufruct and Section 14 ErbStG
A reserved usufruct does not shift the ten-year tax period. A later gratuitous waiver is a further transfer (Section 7 (1) no. 1 ErbStG) that is aggregated with the gift if made within ten years. The consequences of a waiver are explained in the article Waiver of usufruct against compensation after the BFH judgment.
Period 2: Compulsory Share Supplement under Section 2325 (3) BGB
The Phase-Out
The person entitled to a compulsory share can demand the amount by which his or her compulsory share increases if a gift by the testator is added to the estate (Section 2325 (1) BGB). For deaths from 2010, a sliding model applies: the gift is taken into account in full within the first year before the death and, within each further year, one tenth less. Once ten years have passed since performance, it is disregarded (Section 2325 (3) sentences 1 and 2 BGB).
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Time between performance and death | Share taken into account |
|---|---|
| up to 1 year | 100 % |
| more than 1 to 2 years | 90 % |
| more than 2 to 3 years | 80 % |
| more than 3 to 4 years | 70 % |
| more than 4 to 5 years | 60 % |
| more than 5 to 6 years | 50 % |
| more than 6 to 7 years | 40 % |
| more than 7 to 8 years | 30 % |
| more than 8 to 9 years | 20 % |
| more than 9 to 10 years | 10 % |
| more than 10 years | 0 % |
Valuation follows Section 2325 (2) BGB: consumable items such as money at the value at the time of the gift, other objects at the value at the time of death, but at most at the lower value at the time of the gift.
Start of the Period: Performance and Economic Separation
The period begins with the “performance of the donated object”. For this, the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) looks to the occurrence of the performance result, for real property therefore to registration in the land register (BGH, judgment of 29.06.2016, IV ZR 474/15, para. 8, referring to the senate judgment of 02.12.1987, BGHZ 102, 289). An economic view is added: there is performance only if the testator definitively gives up his or her position as owner and also renounces continuing to use the object to a substantial extent. This line from the leading judgment of 27.04.1994 (IV ZR 132/93, BGHZ 125, 395) also applies to the version in force since 2010 (IV ZR 474/15, paras. 9 and 10).
Special Case: Usufruct and Right of Residence
- Reserved usufruct over the whole object: If the donor reserves the usufruct without restriction, he or she has not given up the “enjoyment” of the gift; the period does not begin (IV ZR 474/15, para. 9, on the case IV ZR 132/93).
- Right of residence over parts of the house: It prevents the start of the period only in exceptional cases. The circumstances of the individual case are decisive. In the BGH case, a right of residence on the ground floor of a three-storey house without the right to let it to third parties was not sufficient; the period ran from registration (IV ZR 474/15, headnote, paras. 15 to 17).
In our assessment, on a later waiver of the usufruct the period begins at the earliest with that waiver; if the usufruct ends only with death, the gift counts in full. Whether a partial waiver suffices must be examined in the individual case.
Special Case: Spouses
If the gift was made to the spouse, the period does not begin before the marriage is dissolved (Section 2325 (3) sentence 3 BGB). If the marriage ends with the death of the donor, the gift counts in full, even after decades; on divorce, the period begins with the dissolution.
Calculation Example: Phase-Out
Assumptions (fictitious): the widowed mother Ingrid transfers a house worth 200,000 EUR to her daughter Lena without reserving any rights. Registration in the land register takes place on 15.03.2019. Ingrid dies on 01.10.2026 and appoints Lena as sole heir. Her son Paul is disinherited. The value of the house is unchanged at the time of death; an adjustment for purchasing power is disregarded for simplicity.
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Step | Result |
|---|---|
| Time between registration and death | 7 full years and a good 6 months |
| The gift falls in the | 8th year before the death |
| Share taken into account (100 % minus 7 x 10 %) | 30 % |
| Value to be applied (200,000 EUR x 30 %) | 60,000 EUR |
| Compulsory share quota of Paul (statutory share 1/2, half of it) | 1/4 |
| Compulsory share supplement (60,000 EUR x 1/4) | 15,000 EUR |
Variant: had Ingrid reserved the usufruct over the whole house and kept it until her death, the period would not have started. The full 200,000 EUR would be applied, and the supplement would be 50,000 EUR. If the values at the time of the gift and at the time of death differ, the valuation of the usufruct under Section 2325 (2) BGB must be examined separately.
Paul first directs the claim against the heiress; to the extent the heir is not obliged, the recipient is liable under the law of unjust enrichment and can avert the claim by payment (Section 2329 (1) and (2) BGB). The claim against the recipient becomes time-barred; the period begins with the death (Section 2332 (1) BGB). How the compulsory share itself and the supplement are asserted is shown in the article Compulsory share for children: inheriting despite a will.
Period 3: Reclaim Because of Impoverishment in a Nursing Care Case (Sections 528, 529 BGB)
Requirements and Averting the Claim
If, after the gift, the donor is no longer able to meet his or her appropriate maintenance or to fulfil his or her statutory maintenance obligations, he or she can demand the return of the gift from the recipient under the law of unjust enrichment (Section 528 (1) sentence 1 BGB). The recipient can avert the return by paying the amount required for maintenance (Section 528 (1) sentence 2 BGB). For nursing home costs, this as a rule means not returning the property but ongoing payments in the amount of the funding gap until the value of the gift is reached. Among several recipients, the earlier recipient is liable only to the extent the later recipient is not obliged (Section 528 (2) BGB).
Transfer to the Social Assistance Authority
If the donor receives social assistance, for example help with nursing care, the social assistance authority can, by written notice to the recipient, cause the reclaim claim to pass to it up to the amount of its expenditure (Section 93 (1) sentence 1 SGB XII).
Practical error: Many families rely on the annual income limit of 100,000 EUR for parental maintenance. It is in Section 94 (1a) SGB XII and, according to its wording, concerns only maintenance claims. The reclaim of a gift is transferred under Section 93 SGB XII, which has no such limit. A child who received a gift can therefore be liable from the gift even if he or she owes no parental maintenance. Even then, however, the recipient’s own appropriate maintenance in keeping with his or her station remains protected (Section 529 (2) BGB). How relatives can protect themselves against such claims is covered in the article How relatives are freed from social assistance reclaims for nursing care costs.
The 10-Year Period for a Gift and a Nursing Care Case
The claim is excluded if, at the time need arises, ten years have passed since performance of the gift (Section 529 (1) BGB). What matters is the occurrence of need, not the notification by the social welfare office. There is no phase-out: within the period the claim exists up to the full value, afterwards not at all.
The start of the period also differs from compulsory share law. For real property, it suffices for performance within the meaning of Section 529 (1) BGB that, after a gift contract in proper form and conveyance, the application for registration has been filed with the land registry; registration itself does not matter (BGH, judgment of 19.07.2011, X ZR 140/10, headnote a). A reserved lifelong right of use does not prevent the period from starting (headnote b). The reason is the different protective purpose: Section 528 BGB secures the donor’s maintenance, not persons entitled to a compulsory share (para. 18).
The claim is also excluded where need was caused intentionally or by gross negligence (Section 529 (1) BGB) and to the extent the recipient would otherwise endanger his or her own appropriate maintenance in keeping with his or her station or his or her maintenance obligations (Section 529 (2) BGB).
Calculation Example: Expiry of the Period in a Nursing Care Case
Assumptions (fictitious): father Herbert gives his daughter Sabine an apartment with a market value of 200,000 EUR and reserves a right of residence, the value of which is assumed here to be 50,000 EUR. Conveyance and the application for registration with the land registry take place on 10.05.2016.
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Occurrence of need | Result |
|---|---|
| 01.03.2026 | period not expired, reclaim possible |
| 11.05.2026 | ten years have passed (period ends at the end of 10.05.2026, Sections 187 (1), 188 (2) BGB), reclaim excluded |
With need from 01.03.2026 and a funding gap of 1,500 EUR per month, Sabine can avert the return by payment. In our assessment, the right of residence should reduce the value to be returned, because Sabine is enriched only by the encumbered apartment (Section 528 (1) sentence 1 BGB with Section 818 BGB); how the right is to be valued in the individual case depends on the circumstances. By way of example, 150,000 EUR would then be applied instead of 200,000 EUR; arithmetically that is enough for 100 months instead of about 133. The right of residence changes nothing about the running of the period.
Gift tax lapses retroactively to the extent a gift had to be returned because of a right of reclaim or the return was averted by payment under Section 528 (1) sentence 2 BGB (Section 29 (1) nos. 1 and 2 ErbStG).
Other Periods That Are Often Confused
- Revocation for gross ingratitude: For serious misconduct by the recipient (Section 530 (1) BGB), no ten-year period applies; revocation is excluded if one year has passed since knowledge of the ground or the donor has forgiven (Section 532 BGB). In our assessment, a mere break in contact will regularly not suffice.
- Contestation by creditors: Outside insolvency, creditors can contest gratuitous transfers if they were made not earlier than four years before the contestation (Section 4 (1) of the Creditor Avoidance Act, AnfG); in insolvency, gratuitous transfers within four years before the filing of the petition (Section 134 (1) of the Insolvency Code, InsO). If the donor acts with the intent to disadvantage his or her creditors and the recipient knows of this intent, the period is ten years; knowledge is presumed under the conditions stated there (Section 3 (1) AnfG, Section 133 (1) InsO).
- Moving abroad: The three gift periods are not to be confused with the periods that apply to German inheritance and gift tax after a move abroad. If the donor or the recipient is a German national and has not stayed abroad permanently for longer than five years without having a residence in Germany, the gift remains subject to unlimited tax liability (Section 2 (1) no. 1 sentence 2 letter b ErbStG); beyond that, extended limited tax liability under the Foreign Tax Act on emigration can apply (Section 4 AStG).
Common Planning Errors
- Wrong date: For the compulsory share, registration in the land register counts for real property; for the reclaim, the application for registration already counts. Both dates belong in the file.
- Notification forgotten: An acquisition subject to gift tax must be notified within three months, also by the donor (Section 30 (1) and (2) ErbStG), except where there is judicial or notarial recording (Section 30 (3) sentence 2 ErbStG). A gift that is not notified can have tax criminal law consequences; in addition, the tax office then does not know of the earlier acquisition.
If the tax treatment of a planned transfer is unclear, for example with a staggered plan including a waiver of usufruct, a binding ruling under Section 89 (2) AO can be requested in advance, as is also used before a move abroad; it is subject to a fee (Section 89 (3) to (7) AO; where the amount in dispute is below 10,000 euros, no fee is charged, Section 89 (5) AO) and applies only to the facts exactly described. Embedding it in an overall strategy with a will and provision is shown on the page on estate planning.
Conclusion: Placing the Gift and the 10-Year Period Correctly
- Tax (Section 14 ErbStG): ten years of aggregation, counted backwards from the last acquisition; afterwards a new allowance. A usufruct changes nothing about this.
- Compulsory share (Section 2325 (3) BGB): phase-out by one tenth per year; no start of the period with a reserved usufruct over the whole object, and for spouses not before the marriage is dissolved.
- Nursing care (Sections 528, 529 BGB): full reclaim if need arises within ten years; for real property the period starts already with the application for registration, despite a reserved right of use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is every gift settled after ten years?
No. Tax aggregation and the reclaim in a nursing care case lapse after ten years under the rules described. For the compulsory share, with a reserved usufruct or a gift to the spouse the period may not have started at all.
Does the 10-year period run for a gift with a usufruct?
For tax and nursing care, yes. For the compulsory share supplement, according to the BGH the period does not begin with an unrestrictedly reserved usufruct; a right of residence over parts of the house prevents it only exceptionally.
From when is a gifted house safe from the social welfare office?
If need arises only after ten years have passed since performance (Section 529 (1) BGB); for real property, counting starts from the application for registration after conveyance.
How often can I use the gift allowance?
Once per donor and recipient within ten years. Afterwards it is available again. Father and mother each have a separate allowance of 400,000 EUR in relation to each child.
Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm, with a focus on international inheritance law, tax law and asset protection in Munich, advise parents, children and asset owners on planning gifts during their lifetime, from using the allowances through structuring usufruct and rights of reclaim to the consequences for the compulsory share and nursing care cases. Dr. Fiala has published extensively on emigration and asset protection. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation. This article does not replace advice in an individual case.
Sources
Each accessed on 25 and 26 October 2026.
- Sections 2, 7, 9, 14, 15, 16, 19, 29, 30 ErbStG, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/erbstg_1974/
- Sections 187, 188, 528, 529, 530, 532 BGB, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__529.html
- Sections 2325, 2329, 2332 BGB, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__2325.html
- Sections 93, 94 SGB XII, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/sgb_12/__93.html
- Sections 3, 4 AnfG, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/anfg_1999/__4.html; Sections 133, 134 InsO, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/inso/__134.html
- Section 4 AStG, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/astg/__4.html; Section 89 AO, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/ao_1977/__89.html
- BFH, judgment of 28.03.2012, II R 43/11 (calculation of the ten-year period; execution for real property with reference to II R 26/02), https://www.bundesfinanzhof.de/de/entscheidung/entscheidungen-online/detail/STRE201210143/
- BGH, judgment of 29.06.2016, IV ZR 474/15 (start of period Section 2325 (3) BGB, right of residence; with reference to BGH, judgment of 27.04.1994, IV ZR 132/93, BGHZ 125, 395), https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/Zivilsenate/IV_ZS/2015/IV_ZR_474-15.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=1
- BGH, judgment of 19.07.2011, X ZR 140/10 (start of period Section 529 BGB), https://www.bundesgerichtshof.de/SharedDocs/Entscheidungen/DE/Zivilsenate/X_ZS/2010/X_ZR_140-10.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=1
- Federal Constitutional Court, press release no. 48/2026 of 30.07.2026 (1 BvF 1/23), https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2026/bvg26-048.html
- Federal Constitutional Court, press release no. 49/2026 of 30.07.2026 (1 BvR 804/22), https://www.bundesverfassungsgericht.de/SharedDocs/Pressemitteilungen/DE/2026/bvg26-049.html
- Section 818 BGB, https://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/bgb/__818.html