Anyone who has disclaimed an inheritance and later finds that the estate did contain assets will ask whether the disclaimer (Erbausschlagung) can be contested. German law allows this, but only under narrow conditions: there must be a ground for contestation (Anfechtungsgrund) recognised by statute, a short deadline must be met, and the declaration must take the same form as the disclaimer itself. Where a foreign element is involved, further questions arise about the length of the deadline, certification and the competent court. This article explains the contestation of a disclaimer under Sections 1954 to 1957 of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB), distinguishes mistakes that count from mistakes that do not, and shows the consequences of a successful contestation for you and for the heirs who stepped in (legal position: October 2026).
The reverse situation has to be distinguished: anyone who accepted the inheritance or let the disclaimer period (Ausschlagungsfrist) lapse and now wants to get out of an over-indebted estate is contesting the acceptance or the missed deadline. That is not the subject of this article. How the deadline and form of the disclaimer itself are handled where a foreign element is involved is covered in the article on disclaiming an inheritance with a foreign connection.
Basic Rule: The Disclaimer Is Final
Once a disclaimer is effective, the inheritance is deemed not to have passed to the person disclaiming under Section 1953 (1) BGB. Under Section 1953 (2) BGB the inheritance passes retroactively to whoever would have been called to succeed if the person disclaiming had not been alive at the time of death, for example the person’s own children or the deceased’s siblings.
The law does not provide for revoking a disclaimer. The only statutory way back is contestation. It requires that a defect of intention was present when the disclaimer was declared, one recognised by the general provisions of Sections 119 et seq. BGB. The special succession-law provisions of Sections 1954 to 1957 BGB regulate deadline, form and effect, but according to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) they do not widen the grounds for contestation (BGH, order of 22 March 2023, IV ZB 12/22).
Which Grounds for Contestation Come into Question?
Mistake as to the Declaration and as to Its Content (Section 119 (1) BGB)
A mistake as to the declaration (Erklärungsirrtum) exists where someone did not want to make a declaration of this content at all, for example because they signed the wrong form. Such cases are rare.
A mistake as to content (Inhaltsirrtum) is invoked more often: the declarant knows what they are saying but is wrong about the legal meaning of the declaration. Such a mistake about legal consequences counts only if it concerns the direct legal effects of the disclaimer. Someone who did not know that the disclaimer costs them their position as heir could rely on it. A mistake about merely indirect consequences, which arise only from other provisions, is not enough.
Mistake About Who Succeeds: An Irrelevant Mistake of Motive
In practice an inheritance is often disclaimed in order to steer it to a particular person, frequently the surviving parent. Lawyers speak of a steering disclaimer (lenkende Ausschlagung). If the plan goes wrong because other persons succeed under the statutory order of succession, for example half-siblings of the deceased or grandchildren, those who disclaimed want to undo their declaration.
The Federal Court of Justice decided this question by order of 22 March 2023 (IV ZB 12/22): if the person disclaiming is mistaken about who becomes heir in their place, that is only a mistake about an indirect legal consequence of the disclaimer. Who succeeds does not follow from the declaration of disclaimer but from the statutory or testamentary order of succession. Such a mistake of motive does not entitle the person to contest under Section 119 (1) BGB. According to the BGH this applies even where the person disclaiming pursued the passing of the inheritance to a particular person as the main purpose. For the BGH, legal certainty is decisive; the earlier contrary view of individual higher regional courts is therefore obsolete for practice. In the decided case the descendants had disclaimed so that the widow would become sole heir; in fact half-siblings of the deceased came into the succession alongside her.
Anyone who wants to achieve a particular result by disclaiming should therefore check the entire order of succession beforehand, including any substitute heirs under a will and the preliminary question whether German inheritance law applies at all. Notes on this can be found in the article on statutory succession on emigration.
Mistake About a Characteristic of the Estate (Section 119 (2) BGB)
The most important ground for contestation in practice is a mistake about a characteristic of the estate that is regarded as essential in business dealings. The over-indebtedness of the estate can be such a characteristic. What matters, however, is what the mistake relates to:
- Mistake about the composition: It can count if you were mistaken about what the estate consisted of, that is, which assets and which liabilities belong to it. Typical examples are an account, a securities account or a plot of land you knew nothing about when you disclaimed, or a debt you believed existed but which had already been repaid.
- Mistake about the value: By contrast, it is generally irrelevant if you merely valued objects known to you incorrectly. The Higher Regional Court of Zweibrücken, by order of 14 August 2024 (8 W 102/23), rejected the contestation by an heiress who had considered an encumbered property worthless; after its later sale, the proceeds exceeded the liabilities. That was a misjudgement of value, not a mistake about the composition.
- Speculative disclaimer: Anyone who disclaims without any examination because they generally assume that the estate is over-indebted can regularly not rely on a mistake later. Anyone who decides knowingly on an unsecured basis accepts the risk.
In addition, the mistake must have been causal: had you known the true composition, you would not, on a reasonable assessment, have disclaimed. A find of a few hundred euros alongside considerable debts will hardly suffice. In the Zweibrücken case, too, a previously unknown bank account had turned up; the court regarded this as a mistake about the composition but denied that it was causal for the disclaimer.
Fraud and Duress (Section 123 BGB)
A disclaimer can also be contested if you were induced to make it by fraudulent misrepresentation or unlawful threat, for example where a person called to succeed knowingly conceals a savings book and claims there are only debts. In the case of duress, the deadline begins only when the coercive situation ends (Section 1954 (2) BGB). Correspondence and messages should be secured early.
Special Case: Restrictions That Have Fallen Away (Section 2308 BGB)
A compulsory-share-entitled heir (pflichtteilsberechtigter Erbe) who was restricted or burdened under Section 2306 BGB by a subsequent heirship, an executorship, a legacy or an obligation (Auflage) and therefore disclaimed, can contest the disclaimer under Section 2308 (1) BGB if the restriction or burden had already fallen away at the time of the disclaimer and the heir did not know this. This concerns, for example, a legacy that the legatee had previously disclaimed.
Overview: Relevant or Not?
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Situation | Classification |
|---|---|
| Signed the wrong form, acceptance was intended | Mistake as to the declaration, relevant in principle |
| Unknown bank account or plot of land turns up | Mistake about the composition, can be relevant |
| Debt believed to exist had already been repaid | Mistake about the composition, can be relevant |
| Known property fetches a higher price than expected | Mistake about the value, generally irrelevant |
| General assumption of over-indebtedness without checking | Speculative decision, generally irrelevant |
| Half-siblings or grandchildren inherit instead of the mother | Mistake about an indirect consequence, irrelevant (BGH IV ZB 12/22) |
| Co-heir knowingly concealed assets | Fraudulent misrepresentation, Section 123 BGB |
| Restriction under Section 2306 BGB had already fallen away | Special contestation under Section 2308 BGB |
The Contestation Deadline Under Section 1954 BGB
Under Section 1954 (1) BGB, the contestation must take place within six weeks. In the case of duress the deadline begins when the coercive situation ends; in all other cases it begins at the point at which you become aware of the ground for contestation (Section 1954 (2) sentence 1 BGB). For the running of the deadline the limitation provisions of Sections 206, 210 and 211 BGB apply accordingly, for example in the case of force majeure or for heirs without a statutory representative.
What matters is knowledge of the facts that give rise to the mistake, for example receipt of a bank statement or of a notice from the person called to succeed about a previously unknown plot of land. According to a widespread view in the case law, the start of the deadline is not postponed if you learn only later, through legal advice, that contestation is possible at all. Anyone who receives new information about the estate should therefore note the date and have it reviewed immediately.
Under Section 1954 (3) BGB the deadline is six months if the deceased had their last domicile only abroad or if the heir is abroad when the deadline begins. The same standards apply as for the disclaimer period in Section 1944 (3) BGB: an additional domicile of the deceased in Germany rules out the first variant, and for the second variant a day trip to a neighbouring country is not enough. The stay is to be assessed at the time of knowledge of the ground for contestation, not at the time of the disclaimer.
Irrespective of knowledge, contestation is excluded under Section 1954 (4) BGB once 30 years have passed since the disclaimer.
Form: Declaration to the Probate Court
Under Section 1955 sentence 1 BGB, contestation takes place by declaration to the probate court (Nachlassgericht). Under Section 1955 sentence 2 BGB, the provisions of Section 1945 BGB apply to the declaration. It must be made for the record of the probate court or in publicly certified form; a letter, email or fax is not sufficient. An agent needs a publicly certified power of attorney (Section 1945 (3) BGB).
How strictly this is applied is shown by an order of the Higher Regional Court of Bamberg of 21 March 2022 (2 W 35/21): a lawyer had submitted the notarially certified declaration of contestation in time as a PDF via the special electronic lawyers’ mailbox; the original arrived two days after the deadline had expired. The court did not regard the form as satisfied. What preserves the deadline is the timely receipt of the declaration in proper form by the probate court.
In principle the probate court that is competent for the estate has jurisdiction. Under Section 344 (7) of the Act on Proceedings in Family Matters and in Matters of Non-Contentious Jurisdiction (FamFG), the contestation of a disclaimer can additionally be made before the probate court in whose district the person contesting has their habitual abode; that court forwards the declaration. Which court is competent where the deceased lived abroad is explained in the article on jurisdiction of the probate court for a residence abroad.
In terms of content, the declaration should identify the succession (name, date of death, file number), name the disclaimer being contested, and state the ground for contestation and the date of knowledge.
The probate court initially merely receives the declaration. According to the case law, it does not examine whether the contestation is effective in separate declaratory proceedings but only in the proceedings for a certificate of inheritance (Erbscheinsverfahren) (Higher Regional Court of Nuremberg, order of 1 December 2021, 1 W 3870/21). For you this means: after the contestation a separate application for a certificate of inheritance is generally required, in which the ground for contestation and compliance with the deadline must be set out and, where necessary, proven.
Contesting from Abroad
Heirs who live abroad do not have to travel to Germany to contest. The signature can be certified by a German consular officer (Section 10 of the Consular Act, Konsulargesetz); this certification is equivalent to that of a domestic notary. Alternatively, a foreign notary may be considered; whether the German court then requires an apostille or legalisation depends on the issuing state. The consulate does not receive the declaration with effect for the probate court. It becomes effective only when the original reaches the probate court. With international postal times and appointments at diplomatic missions, even six months are quickly used up.
For heirs with their habitual residence in another EU member state (except Denmark and Ireland), Article 13 of the EU Succession Regulation (EuErbVO) opens up the possibility of making declarations on the acceptance or disclaimer of the inheritance before the courts of their state of residence, if the law there so provides. The wording does not expressly mention the contestation of a disclaimer. Whether the provision covers it has not been conclusively settled. The safer route is therefore a publicly certified declaration submitted to the competent German probate court. Which authority in the state of residence would be competent and which form applies there should be clarified with an adviser on the spot.
All of this assumes that the succession is governed by German inheritance law. Under Article 23 (2) letter e EuErbVO, the conditions and effects of acceptance and disclaimer are governed by the law applicable to the succession, that is, as a rule by the law of the deceased’s last habitual residence. Whether and how a disclaimer can be contested under foreign law can only be clarified with an adviser in the state concerned. The basics are explained in the article on international inheritance law on emigration.
Example: The fictitious heiress Ilse has lived in Portugal for years. Her brother dies in Hamburg in May. She disclaims because she holds a reminder from a debt collection agency and assumes the estate is over-indebted. In September she learns from her niece, who has stepped in, that an unknown building society savings contract of 40,000 euros has been found. From that day, because she is staying in Portugal, a contestation period of six months runs for her. She has her signature certified at the consulate and sends the original by courier to the probate court. Whether the mistake was relevant and causal is examined in the proceedings for a certificate of inheritance.
Consequences of a Successful Contestation
The Contestation Is Deemed Acceptance
Under Section 1957 (1) BGB, the contestation of a disclaimer is deemed acceptance of the inheritance. You have thereby retroactively become heir, with all rights and duties. A renewed disclaimer is not possible. You are liable for the estate liabilities, but you can limit that liability to the estate by estate administration or estate insolvency (Section 1975 BGB). Clarify beforehand, therefore, whether the estate actually has value. With accounts abroad this is often difficult without proof of succession. How an estate administrator also reviews assets abroad and limits liability to the estate is explained in the article on the estate administrator with a foreign connection.
If it turns out after the contestation that this, too, was based on a relevant mistake, the declaration of contestation can itself be contested. Section 344 (7) FamFG expressly presupposes this possibility. Here again narrow conditions and short deadlines apply.
What Happens to the Person Called to Succeed
With an effective contestation the disclaimer lapses retroactively. The person called to succeed therefore did not become heir. Under Section 1957 (2) BGB, the probate court is to notify the contestation to the person to whom the inheritance had passed as a result of the disclaimer. A certificate of inheritance already issued to that person is incorrect and is to be withdrawn by the probate court (Section 2361 BGB). If the person called to succeed has taken possession of items of the estate, the person contesting can demand their return by means of the claim of the heir (Erbschaftsanspruch) under Sections 2018 et seq. BGB; relief applies for possessors of the estate who acted in good faith.
As long as it is unclear whether the contestation is effective, the probate court can appoint an estate custodian (Nachlasspfleger) to secure the estate; that was the case in the Bamberg decision mentioned above. For the particularities where assets are located abroad, see the article on estate custodianship with a foreign connection.
Damages Under Section 122 BGB
Anyone who contests because of a mistake under Section 119 BGB must, under Section 122 (1) BGB, compensate the reliance loss (Vertrauensschaden). Because the disclaimer is to be declared not to a private person but to the probate court, the persons who can claim are third parties who relied on the validity of the disclaimer, typically the person called to succeed who incurred costs for a certificate of inheritance, a clearance or a valuation. Only the loss arising from the reliance is compensated, not a lost share of the estate. The duty to compensate lapses under Section 122 (2) BGB if the injured party knew or should have known of the ground for contestation, for example because they knew of the concealed account. In the case of contestation for fraud or duress under Section 123 BGB, Section 122 BGB does not apply.
Tax Consequences
With the contestation you are an acquirer upon death; your tax class and your allowances then apply. If a tax assessment has already been issued to the person called to succeed, the consequences must be clarified on both sides, and where a person lives abroad also possible double taxation; see the article on inheritance tax and double taxation treaties.
Typical Mistakes in Practice
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Mistake | Consequence | Better |
|---|---|---|
| Disclaiming on mere suspicion of over-indebtedness | No relevant mistake, contestation fails | Obtain and document bank, land register and creditor information before disclaiming |
| Steering disclaimer without checking the order of succession | Wrong person inherits, contestation inadmissible (BGH IV ZB 12/22) | Have the entire order of succession calculated in advance |
| Waiting after learning new facts | Deadline expires | Note the date of knowledge, obtain advice immediately |
| Contestation by letter, email or PDF | Form not satisfied | Public certification, original to the court in time |
| Postal time from abroad not planned for | Original arrives too late | Courier with tracking, build in a buffer |
| Contestation without checking the debts | Liability for estate liabilities | Clarify the composition of the estate in advance, consider limiting liability |
If a mistake is attributable to incorrect advice, for example from the notary who authenticated the declaration, liability of the notary may come into question in an individual case; this must be examined separately.
Conclusion
A disclaimer of inheritance can be contested only if a defect of intention recognised by law exists. Of practical importance above all is the mistake about the composition of the estate, that is, about unknown assets or supposed debts. Anyone who merely misjudges the value, speculates generally about over-indebtedness, or is mistaken about who inherits in their place cannot contest. The contestation must reach the probate court in publicly certified form within six weeks, or within six months where a foreign element is involved, from knowledge of the ground for contestation. It operates as acceptance, displaces the person called to succeed and can trigger duties to pay damages. The most effective prevention is a careful examination of the estate before disclaiming.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I simply revoke a disclaimer of inheritance?
No. The law does not provide for revocation. Only contestation under Sections 1954 to 1957 BGB is possible, where a ground for contestation such as a relevant mistake, fraud or duress exists.
How much time do I have to contest the disclaimer?
Six weeks from knowledge of the ground for contestation, and in the case of duress from the end of the coercive situation. It is six months if the deceased had their last domicile only abroad or you are abroad when the deadline begins. After 30 years contestation is excluded.
Is it enough if the estate turns out to be worth more?
Not without more. A mistake about the composition of the estate, such as an unknown account, is relevant. A mere misjudgement of the value of known items is not sufficient according to the case law.
I disclaimed so that my mother would inherit alone. Now others inherit too. Can I contest?
Not according to the order of the Federal Court of Justice of 22 March 2023 (IV ZB 12/22). The mistake about who becomes heir in your place is an irrelevant mistake of motive.
Can I declare the contestation from abroad?
Yes. Your signature can be certified at the German consulate or by a foreign notary, if necessary with an apostille. What matters is that the original reaches the competent German probate court in time.
Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm, with a focus on international inheritance law, tax law and asset protection in Munich, advise heirs in Germany and abroad on contesting a disclaimer of inheritance, from examining the ground for contestation and making the declaration in time from abroad to the proceedings for a certificate of inheritance and the inheritance tax assessment. Dr. Fiala has published extensively on emigration and asset protection. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.