Inheriting Italian Property: Succession Law and Inheritance Tax from a German Perspective

Inheriting Italian Property: Succession Law and Inheritance Tax from a German Perspective

Inheriting Italian Property: German Inheritance Tax

An estate that includes property in Italy regularly brings German heirs to a point where three legal levels must be considered at the same time: internationally harmonised succession law, Italian forced heirship (Noterbrecht), and the independent German inheritance tax system. Anyone who inherits a holiday home in Tuscany, an apartment on the Ligurian coast or a family home in Apulia has to clarify who actually becomes the heir, in which country and in what amount inheritance tax is due, and how the property is formally re-registered. This article places the German legal position in context, distinguishes it from the Italian particularities and shows the practical steps.

When Is There an Estate With a Connection to Italy?

In practice, a connection to Italy arises in several typical situations, whose legal consequences differ considerably in part:

  • The deceased had his or her last habitual residence in Germany but owned a holiday property in Italy.
  • The deceased had himself or herself emigrated to Italy, for example as a retiree or entrepreneur, and leaves the centre of his or her life there together with the property.
  • The property has been inherited over several generations without ever being formally re-registered in the names of the current owners.
  • The heirs live in Germany while significant estate assets are located in Italy.

In all these cases the same basic questions arise: Which succession law determines who becomes the heir, which taxes arise in which country, and which steps are needed for a legally secure re-registration?

Which Succession Law Applies to the Italian Property?

The EU Succession Regulation: Unity of the Estate Instead of the Situs Principle

Since 17 August 2015, the EU Succession Regulation (Regulation (EU) No 650/2012, EuErbVO) determines which succession law applies in estates connected with the participating EU Member States. Under Article 21 (1) EuErbVO, the whole succession to the estate is governed by the law of the state in which the deceased had his or her habitual residence at the time of death. The decisive principle is unity of the estate (Nachlasseinheit): in principle the same succession law applies to the Italian property as to the other assets; the widespread misconception that property is always inherited under the law of the state where it is situated (Belegenheitsprinzip) does not apply here. The mechanics of the Regulation are explained in detail in the article International inheritance law when emigrating: how the EuErbVO determines which law applies.

If the deceased habitually lived in Germany until death, German succession law in principle also applies to the Italian property. If he or she last had his or her habitual residence in Italy, for example after emigrating, Italian succession law in principle applies to the entire estate, including an account that remained in Germany. Whether and under what conditions German succession law continues to have effect after a move is dealt with in more depth in the article German inheritance law where the deceased lived abroad.

Choice of German Law

Anyone who wants to avoid his or her Italian property being inherited under Italian law with its stricter forced heirship can use the choice of law under Article 22 EuErbVO: a person may expressly choose, in a will or inheritance contract, the law of the state of which he or she is a national. Such a choice of German law in principle also covers the Italian property and removes the estate as a whole from Italian substantive succession law. The choice of law must be declared expressly or result from the terms of a disposition of property upon death; it is therefore also possible by implication, for example where the will refers to German provisions. For legal certainty it should be formulated expressly. The law that can be chosen is that of the state of which the deceased is a national at the time of the choice or at the time of death (Article 22 (1) and (2) EuErbVO). Unlike, for example, in relation to Turkey or successor states of the former Soviet Union, there are no older bilateral treaties with Italy that would take precedence over the EuErbVO; a split of the estate between movable and immovable property therefore does not occur.

Compulsory Share in Germany and Forced Heirship in Italy: An Important Difference

If the estate is inherited under Italian law, because the deceased had his or her last habitual residence there or Italian law became applicable, Italian forced heirship also applies to the relatives designated there as “legittimari”. The basic idea is comparable to the German compulsory share (Pflichtteil): protecting close relatives from complete disinheritance. In their structural design, however, the two systems differ markedly, for example in the legal nature of the claim, the circle of those entitled and the manner of enforcement. The German compulsory share is a pure monetary claim against the heirs (Section 2303 of the German Civil Code, BGB), for descendants, the spouse and, in the absence of descendants, also the parents.

How Italian forced heirship is designed in detail, in particular which quotas apply, who is entitled and to what extent, how the claim is to be enforced and whether a right of residence in the estate exists, is governed by Italian civil law, which may change and which this article cannot and is not meant to present. For a binding review of whether and in what amount forced heirship exists in the individual case, a lawyer or notary admitted in Italy must be consulted. How compulsory share claims can in principle be enforced from a German perspective where assets are abroad is explained in the article Compulsory share where assets are abroad: how to enforce claims across borders.

Inheritance Tax in Germany: Unlimited Tax Liability Remains

Regardless of the applicable civil law, German inheritance tax liability is determined independently under the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetz, ErbStG). Under Section 2 (1) no. 1 sentence 2 letter a ErbStG, the entire acquisition is subject to unlimited German inheritance tax liability if the deceased was a resident of Germany (Inländer) at the time of death, that is, in particular had his or her residence or habitual abode in Germany; a German national who has not stayed permanently abroad for more than five years without having a residence in Germany is also a resident (Section 2 (1) no. 1 sentence 2 letter b ErbStG); the same legal consequence applies if the acquirer is a resident. The Italian holiday property is thus subject to German inheritance tax on its entire value as soon as the deceased or the heir meets these requirements.

Why Double Taxation Can Occur: No Inheritance Tax Treaty With Italy

Germany and Italy have a double taxation treaty on income tax. A separate treaty to avoid double taxation on inheritance tax, however, does not exist between the two states (Federal Ministry of Finance overview of the status of double taxation treaties); in the field of inheritance and gift tax, Germany has concluded such treaties with only a very small number of states, and Italy is not one of them. If Italy levies its own inheritance tax on the property situated there and Germany at the same time levies German inheritance tax on the same acquisition under Section 2 (1) no. 1 ErbStG, genuine double taxation therefore threatens. How the absence of such a treaty has an effect in general is explained in more detail in the article Inheritance tax and double taxation treaties: when foreign assets are taxed twice.

Credit under Section 21 ErbStG

Where there is no double taxation treaty, the remaining instrument against double taxation is the credit under Section 21 ErbStG: acquirers who are subject abroad to a comparable tax on their foreign assets can have it credited on application. The credit is limited to the part of the German inheritance tax attributable to the foreign assets (maximum amount); if the Italian tax is higher, the excess remains without credit (Section 21 (1) ErbStG). Requirements: unlimited tax liability under Section 2 (1) no. 1 sentence 2 letters a and b ErbStG; proof of assessment and payment of the foreign tax by documents, certified and translated where necessary; where only part of the assets are abroad or assets are in several states, only a proportionate credit, separate for each state; and the foreign tax is creditable only if the German inheritance tax on the foreign assets arose within five years of the foreign inheritance tax arising. The credit is always made on application only, not ex officio.

A frequently overlooked particularity: because the procedures run at different speeds, Italian inheritance tax is sometimes assessed only after the German notice has already become final. The Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) has decided that the subsequent payment of a foreign inheritance or gift tax is a retroactive event within the meaning of Section 175 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO), so that the final German notice can still be amended (Federal Fiscal Court, judgment of 22 September 2010, file no. II R 54/09). The decision concerned a gift tax case with a connection to Switzerland but expressly relied on the purpose of Section 21 ErbStG, so the principles may also be significant for estates involving Italy.

If neither the deceased nor the acquirer was subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany at the time of death, limited German inheritance tax liability may arise instead, which is confined to certain domestic assets. An Italian property then in principle does not count as German domestic property and is regularly not subject to German inheritance tax; the credit under Section 21 ErbStG, moreover, specifically presupposes unlimited tax liability and is not available in the case of limited tax liability.

Italian Inheritance Tax on the Property: A Rough Classification

Italian inheritance tax is an independent tax under Italian law that is roughly based on the degree of kinship between the deceased and the acquirer, with different rates and allowances for spouses and children, siblings, other relatives and all other persons; in addition, for an inherited property, further taxes linked to the cadastral value may arise. For the binding amount of rates, allowances and ancillary taxes in the individual case, an Italian lawyer or tax adviser, or the competent Italian tax authority (Agenzia delle Entrate), must always be consulted, since these amounts may change. Heirs must also file an Italian inheritance tax return (“dichiarazione di successione”) on time; the exact deadline and the competent office should be confirmed in the individual case by an Italian adviser.

Practical Steps: From Proof of Inheritance to Re-registration in the Italian Land Register

The following steps can be distinguished for the practical handling; the German steps are presented here reliably, the Italian ones only as rough guidance:

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Step Content Legal level
1. Clarify the succession law Determine which succession law applies under Article 21 or Article 22 EuErbVO German/European
2. Obtain proof of inheritance Apply for a certificate of inheritance (Erbschein) from the German probate court and/or a European Certificate of Succession German/European
3. Consider acceptance or disclaimer Decide within the disclaimer period under Section 1944 BGB whether to accept or disclaim the inheritance German
4. Italian inheritance tax return File the “dichiarazione di successione” with the competent Italian tax office Italian (rough indication only)
5. Land register/cadastre re-registration Re-registration in the Italian property and cadastral register after acceptance of the inheritance Italian (rough indication only)
6. Notify German inheritance tax Notification within three months of obtaining knowledge to the competent German tax office under Section 30 ErbStG German
7. Apply for credit Apply for credit of the Italian tax under Section 21 ErbStG as soon as it has been paid German

The European Certificate of Succession considerably facilitates proof of the position as heir vis-a-vis Italian authorities within the EU, but does not in every case replace additional declarations on the formal acceptance of the inheritance required under Italian law. Which German probate court is competent to issue the certificate of inheritance or the European Certificate of Succession, in particular where the deceased lived abroad for a time, is explained in the article Jurisdiction of the probate court where the deceased lived abroad: which court decides on the estate?.

When disclaiming an over-indebted or unwanted inheritance, the deadline needs particular attention: if German succession law applies (residence in Germany or choice of law), Section 1944 BGB applies: six weeks, and where there is a foreign connection under Section 1944 (3) BGB six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or the heir is abroad when the period begins. If the estate is governed by Italian law, the period and the effect of the disclaimer are governed by that law; a declaration can also be made before the court at the declarant’s habitual residence, to the extent that the law of that state provides for this (Article 23 (2) letter e and Article 13 EuErbVO). Further particularities of a disclaimer with a foreign connection are set out in the article Disclaiming an inheritance with a foreign connection: deadline, form and competent court.

Do Not Forget the German Duty to Notify

Regardless of the state of the Italian proceedings, the separate German duty to notify must be observed: under Section 30 (1) ErbStG, every acquisition subject to inheritance tax must be notified to the tax office within three months of obtaining knowledge, irrespective of whether the Italian property has already been valued or the Italian tax already assessed. What details such a notification must contain where there are foreign assets is explained in the article Inheritance tax: duty to notify where there are foreign assets under Section 30 ErbStG.

Binding Ruling Where the Legal Position Is Unclear

Both the credit under Section 21 ErbStG and the valuation of an Italian property can involve considerable uncertainty in the individual case, for example where the Italian tax is assessed only years later. A binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) under Section 89 (2) AO on a set of facts that has not yet occurred can then be applied for from the competent tax office, provided there is a special interest because of significant tax effects; the application should be decided within six months, for a fee measured by the value of the subject matter. Where there are uncertainties about Italian inheritance tax, it should also be examined whether the Italian tax authority gives a comparable ruling; this depends on Italian procedural law and must be clarified with an Italian adviser.

Conclusion

An estate with property in Italy requires German heirs to separate two levels cleanly: under civil law, since 2015 the EuErbVO regularly determines, by the deceased’s habitual residence and uniformly for the entire estate, which succession law applies, including to the Italian property. For inheritance tax purposes Germany is unaffected by this and, where there is unlimited tax liability, independently levies inheritance tax on the worldwide estate. Because there is no inheritance tax double taxation treaty between Germany and Italy, only the credit under Section 21 ErbStG remains where Italian taxation applies at the same time; its effect can also operate retroactively if the foreign tax is paid only after the German notice has become final. Italian forced heirship is stricter than the German compulsory share, but its exact scope and the re-registration of the property in the Italian land register must be reviewed by an Italian lawyer or notary.

Frequently Asked Questions About Inheriting Italian Property

As a German heir of Italian property, do I have to pay inheritance tax in both countries?

That is possible if you or the deceased were subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany at the time of death and Italy at the same time levies its own inheritance tax on the property situated there. Because there is no inheritance tax double taxation treaty between Germany and Italy, such a double burden can regularly be reduced only through the credit under Section 21 ErbStG, not avoided through a treaty.

Does Italian succession law automatically apply to my Italian property because it is located there?

No. Within the scope of the EuErbVO the principle of unity of the estate applies: the deceased’s habitual residence at the time of death is decisive, not the location of individual assets. If the deceased last lived in Germany, German succession law can therefore also apply to the Italian property.

Can I prevent Italian forced heirship from applying by choosing the applicable law?

A choice of German law under Article 22 EuErbVO, declared expressly or resulting from the terms of a will or inheritance contract (best formulated expressly for legal certainty), can lead to German succession law, including German compulsory share law, applying as a whole, also to the Italian property. Whether the choice of law was made in a valid form should be reviewed by a lawyer.

What is a “dichiarazione di successione” and do I have to file it as a German heir?

It is the Italian inheritance tax return, which in principle must be filed with the competent Italian tax office (Agenzia delle Entrate) within twelve months of the death if estate assets are located in Italy. Italian inheritance tax is 4 percent for spouses and relatives in the direct line above an allowance of 1 million euros per beneficiary, 6 percent for siblings above 100,000 euros, 6 percent for other relatives up to the fourth degree and 8 percent for everyone else. Documents and current amounts should be clarified with an Italian adviser.

What deadline applies if I want to disclaim an over-indebted inheritance that includes Italian property?

If German succession law applies, the disclaimer period under Section 1944 (1) BGB is in principle six weeks and, under Section 1944 (3) BGB, extends to six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or you are abroad when the period begins. If the estate is governed by Italian law, the period and effect are governed by that law. Whether a further declaration under Italian law is needed is clarified by an Italian adviser.

Can I have Italian inheritance tax credited even if the German inheritance tax notice has already become final?

That is possible under certain conditions. According to the case law of the Federal Fiscal Court, the subsequent payment of a foreign inheritance or gift tax is a retroactive event that can allow a final German notice to be amended (Federal Fiscal Court, judgment of 22 September 2010, file no. II R 54/09). The credit must, however, be actively applied for and is subject to the further requirements of Section 21 ErbStG, in particular the five-year period.

Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm have published extensively on international inheritance and tax law for property abroad and advise clients on estates with property in Italy, from clarifying the applicable succession law to crediting inheritance tax. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.

Do you have questions?

Please do not hesitate to call us for an introductory conversation. I will gladly take the time personally to review your case and give you an estimate of the work involved.

That way, you will already be one step further!

You can reach us by phone at +49 89 / 17 90 900 or by clicking the button:

Call now
Portrait Dr. Fiala

Dr. Johannes Fiala

Your lawyer in Munich is reliable and competent, always by your side.

Recommend us

Found what you were looking for? Do you know someone who could use our support? Feel free to recommend us.