Missed the Deadline to Disclaim an Inheritance in Germany: Contestation and Limiting Liability

Missed the Deadline to Disclaim an Inheritance in Germany: Contestation and Limiting Liability

Missed the Inheritance Disclaimer Deadline?

Anyone who wanted to disclaim (ausschlagen) an inheritance but missed the deadline is treated under German law as an heir, with all the rights and all the debts of the deceased. It is typical for heirs to learn of the deceased’s loans, guarantees or tax debts only after the deadline has expired. The law then offers two routes: contestation (Anfechtung), which has the same effect as a disclaimer, and limiting liability to the estate. Both have short deadlines and strict formal requirements. This article explains the legal position as of October 2026 and deals separately with estates that have a foreign connection.

First Step: Has the Deadline Really Expired?

Before considering contestation, check whether the disclaimer period has actually run out. In practice it is not unusual to find that it began later than those affected believe.

Under Section 1944 (1) of the German Civil Code (Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch, BGB), a disclaimer can only be made within six weeks. Under Section 1944 (2) sentence 1 BGB, the period begins only when the heir has learned of the devolution of the inheritance and of the ground on which he or she was called to inherit. The date of death is therefore not decisive. Where the heir is called by will or inheritance contract, the period under Section 1944 (2) sentence 2 BGB does not begin before the probate court has announced the disposition. According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof), a mistake about the facts, or a legal misjudgement that is not untenable from the outset, can even exclude the knowledge that starts the period.

For the running of the period, Section 1944 (2) sentence 3 BGB refers to Sections 206 and 210 BGB. The period is therefore suspended for as long as the heir is prevented from disclaiming by force majeure (Section 206 BGB). If an heir who lacks full legal capacity has no legal representative, the period under Section 210 BGB does not end before the expiry of the disclaimer period counted from the appointment of a representative or the attainment of full legal capacity. Since 1 January 2023 the following also applies to minors and persons under guardianship: if the disclaimer has been declared to the probate court and the required court approval has been applied for, the period is suspended during the approval procedure (Section 1858 (3) BGB, for parents in conjunction with Section 1644 (3) BGB).

Finally, under Section 1944 (3) BGB the period is six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or if the heir was abroad when the period began. A short stay abroad, such as a day trip, is not enough (Federal Court of Justice, order of 16 January 2019, IV ZB 20/18). Anyone who overlooked this variant may not have missed the deadline at all. The details on the length of the period, certification abroad and the competent court are covered in the article on disclaiming an inheritance with a foreign connection.

Checklist for the Start of the Period

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Question Significance for the running of the period
When did I learn for certain of the death and of my position as heir? Earliest possible start of the period
Was I called to inherit by will? Period does not begin before announcement by the probate court
Did I only move up because another heir disclaimed? Own period from knowledge of that devolution
Did the deceased have a residence only abroad, or was I abroad when the period began? Six months instead of six weeks
Did the end of the period fall on a Saturday, Sunday or public holiday? Period ends on the next working day (Section 193 BGB)
Is an approval procedure pending before the family or guardianship court? Suspension under Section 1858 (3) BGB

The Legal Consequence: Acceptance by Lapse of the Period

Once the period has expired, the heir can no longer disclaim under Section 1943 BGB; when the period ends, the inheritance is deemed accepted. This statutory fiction requires no declaration by the heir. Under Section 1967 BGB the heir is liable for the estate’s liabilities, and initially not only with the estate but in principle also with his or her own assets.

There is no extension of the disclaimer period. It is a substantive preclusion period (materielle Ausschlussfrist). That an heir can no longer disclaim after the period has expired is shown by an order of the Thuringian Higher Regional Court (Thüringer Oberlandesgericht): a son had missed the disclaimer period, and his contestation of the missed period failed because of its form (order of 12 October 2015, 6 W 364/15). The rules on restoration of the previous position (Wiedereinsetzung) apply only to periods in court proceedings, not to the substantive disclaimer period.

The same applies if the heir had already accepted before the period expired, expressly or by conduct implying acceptance, for example by applying for a certificate of inheritance.

Route 1: Contesting the Missed Deadline under Section 1956 BGB

Section 1956 BGB provides that the missing of the disclaimer period can be contested in the same way as acceptance. Someone who became an heir merely by remaining silent is thus no worse off than someone who accepted expressly. Under Section 1957 (1) BGB, the contestation of acceptance counts as a disclaimer. The heir is therefore treated as if he or she had disclaimed in time; the inheritance passes to the next person called.

Which Mistakes Are Sufficient?

A ground for contestation under the general rules is required: mistake (Section 119 BGB), fraudulent misrepresentation or duress (Section 123 BGB). In practice two kinds of mistake are usually at issue.

Mistake about the deadline and its consequences. Under the judgment of the Federal Court of Justice of 29 June 2016 (IV ZR 387/15), an heir can contest acceptance of the inheritance because of a mistake if he or she was mistaken about the consequences of acceptance, for example because he or she believed that disclaiming would forfeit the compulsory share (Pflichtteil). What matters is that the mistake concerns the legal consequences of acceptance and was causal for the acceptance; whether this also applies to mere ignorance that silence amounts to acceptance must be assessed on the facts of the individual case. The mistake must have been causal: if the heir would not have disclaimed even with the correct understanding, contestation is excluded. The person contesting must be able to demonstrate this causation in a dispute.

Mistake about the composition of the estate. This is the most common case: the heir let the period pass because he or she considered the estate valuable, and then learns of substantial debts. According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, the over-indebtedness of the estate is an essential characteristic within the meaning of Section 119 (2) BGB (Federal Court of Justice, judgment of 8 February 1989, IVa ZR 98/87, BGHZ 106, 359; confirmed in the order of 10 June 2015, IV ZB 39/14). The 1989 case concerned an heiress who had considered a legacy burdening the estate to be invalid; her declaration, described as a contestation of the missed deadline, was construed as a contestation of acceptance and succeeded.

Distinction: Mistake About a Characteristic or Mere Mistake About Value

Not every disappointment about the estate justifies contestation. The case law distinguishes:

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Situation Classification Contestation
Unknown liability appears, such as a guarantee or a loan Mistake about the composition May be possible
Unknown tax claim against the deceased Mistake about the composition May be possible
Known house was overvalued Mere mistake about value In principle no
Heir hoped for value without any check Knowingly unsecured basis In principle no
Heir did not know that silence counts as acceptance Mistake about legal consequences under Federal Court of Justice IV ZR 387/15 May be possible if causal
General ignorance of inheritance law without a concrete misconception No tangible mistake In principle no

For causation, the Federal Court of Justice applies an objective assessment as at the time the disclaimer period expired (IV ZB 39/14). Circumstances that became known later and have nothing to do with the original mistake are disregarded. Anyone who wants to rely on a mistake must therefore be able to explain what estate he or she assumed existed when the period expired and which concrete liability was unknown.

Deadline for Contestation: Six Weeks, in Certain Foreign Cases Six Months

Contestation itself has a short deadline. Under Section 1954 (1) BGB it is six weeks. Under Section 1954 (2) BGB it begins at the point when the person entitled to contest learns of the ground for contestation, and in the case of duress at the end of the coercive situation. Under Section 1954 (3) BGB it is six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or if the heir is abroad when the period begins. Under Section 1954 (4) BGB contestation is excluded once 30 years have passed since acceptance.

This period too is a preclusion period without restoration of the previous position. In the case before the Thuringian Higher Regional Court, the son had contested in time, but only by a lawyer’s written submission; the certified declaration arrived only after the six weeks had expired. The certified power of attorney of the lawyer did not help because the declaration itself was formally invalid.

Form and Addressee

Under Section 1955 BGB, contestation is made by declaration to the probate court; Section 1945 BGB governs the form. The declaration must therefore be made on record at the probate court (zur Niederschrift) or in publicly certified form. A letter, an email or a simple written submission by a lawyer is not sufficient. Under Section 1945 (3) BGB an authorised representative needs a publicly certified power of attorney. Under Section 344 (7) of the Act on Proceedings in Family Matters and in Matters of Non-Contentious Jurisdiction (FamFG), the declaration can also be made at the probate court in whose district the declarant has his or her habitual abode.

In terms of content, the declaration should contain details of the declarant and the deceased, the file reference, the express contestation, the specific ground for contestation and the point in time at which the declarant learned of it. As a precaution it is advisable to contest both the acceptance and the missing of the period. Whether the contestation is effective is usually clarified only in the proceedings for a certificate of inheritance or in a dispute with creditors.

What Applies After a Successful Contestation

With an effective contestation, the position as heir lapses retroactively. Anyone who has handled estate affairs until then is, under Section 1959 (1) BGB, obliged to the definitive heir like an agent acting without authority. Because contestation counts as a disclaimer (Section 1957 (1) BGB), the probate court should under Section 1953 (3) sentence 1 BGB inform the person to whom the inheritance now passes; a separate disclaimer period runs for that person. Often these are the heir’s own children, for whom a separate disclaimer must be made.

Route 2: Limiting Liability Without Disclaiming

If there is no ground for contestation, or if the contestation period has also expired, the person concerned remains an heir. He or she does not then have to answer with his or her own assets for the debts of the deceased. Under Section 1975 BGB, the heir’s liability is limited to the estate if estate administration (Nachlassverwaltung) has been ordered or estate insolvency proceedings (Nachlassinsolvenzverfahren) have been opened. These instruments remain available after the disclaimer period has expired.

Estate Administration

Under Section 1981 (1) BGB, the probate court must order estate administration if the heir applies for it. For the heir’s application the law provides no two-year period; the period of two years since acceptance in Section 1981 (2) sentence 2 BGB concerns the application of an estate creditor. Under Section 2062 BGB, co-heirs can apply for estate administration only jointly and only before the estate is divided. With the order, the heir loses the power of disposal (Section 1984 BGB); an estate administrator satisfies the creditors, and any surplus goes to the heir. If the estate does not cover the costs, the order can be refused under Section 1982 BGB. On the appointment where assets are located abroad, see the article on the estate administrator for assets abroad.

Estate Insolvency Proceedings and the Duty to File

If the estate is unable to pay its debts or is over-indebted, estate insolvency proceedings are the intended route. Here there is a duty: under Section 1980 (1) BGB the heir must apply without undue delay for the opening of proceedings as soon as he or she learns of the insolvency or over-indebtedness. If the heir breaches this duty, he or she is liable to the creditors for the resulting loss. Under Section 1980 (2) BGB, ignorance caused by negligence is equivalent to knowledge. Anyone who learns of substantial debts after the deadline should therefore examine an insolvency filing in parallel with contestation.

The competent court is the insolvency court in whose district the deceased had his or her general place of jurisdiction (Section 315 of the Insolvency Code, InsO). The two-year limit of Section 319 InsO concerns only the application of an estate creditor, not that of the heir.

Plea of Insufficient Estate if the Estate Does Not Cover a Procedure

If the estate does not even cover the costs of proceedings, Section 1990 BGB applies: if the order of estate administration or the opening of estate insolvency proceedings is not feasible for lack of assets matching the costs, or if the proceedings are terminated or discontinued for that reason, the heir may refuse to satisfy an estate creditor to the extent that the estate is insufficient. The heir must then hand over the existing estate for enforcement. The plea must be raised in the proceedings and reserved in the judgment (Section 780 of the Code of Civil Procedure, ZPO); anyone who is sued and does not apply for the reservation can in principle no longer rely on it later in enforcement.

Public Notice Procedure and Mistakes That Cost the Limitation

To clarify which creditors exist, the heir can apply under Section 1970 BGB for a public notice procedure (Aufgebot) addressed to estate creditors; anyone who does not come forward is, under Section 1973 BGB, satisfied only from the surplus. This must be distinguished from Section 1974 BGB: anyone who asserts a claim later than five years after the death is treated like an excluded creditor, provided the heir did not know of the claim beforehand. If the heir misses a period set for drawing up an inventory (Section 1994 BGB), he or she is liable without limit under Section 2013 BGB; anyone who uses estate assets for himself or herself is obliged to compensate the creditors under Sections 1978 and 1991 BGB where estate administration has been ordered, estate insolvency proceedings opened or the plea of insufficient estate raised.

Overview: Which Route Fits?

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Starting position Obvious route Important deadline
Concrete mistake about debts or about the consequences of the lapse of the period Contestation under Sections 1956, 1954 BGB 6 weeks from knowledge, 6 months in the foreign cases of Section 1954 (3) BGB
Estate unclear, over-indebtedness uncertain Estate administration, public notice procedure No filing deadline for the heir; co-heirs only before division
Estate unable to pay or over-indebted Estate insolvency filing Without undue delay after knowledge (Section 1980 BGB)
Estate does not even cover the costs of proceedings Plea of insufficient estate under Section 1990 BGB Raise in the proceedings, reservation under Section 780 ZPO

Missed Deadline With a Foreign Connection

In estates with a foreign connection, further questions arise.

Does German inheritance law apply? The rules on disclaimer, contestation and liability for estate liabilities are governed by the law applicable to the succession (Erbstatut) (Article 23 (2) letters e and g of the EU Succession Regulation, EuErbVO). In principle the deceased’s last habitual residence is decisive, unless he or she chose the law of his or her nationality under Article 22 EuErbVO. If the deceased last lived in Spain, for example, different deadlines and remedies may apply; a local adviser must then be consulted. How the applicable law is determined is described in the article on international inheritance law when emigrating.

Longer contestation period. If the estate is governed by German law, the contestation period under Section 1954 (3) BGB is six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or the heir was abroad when the period began; any other foreign connection, such as assets abroad, is not enough for this. The certified declaration, for example via a German consulate or a foreign notary with an apostille, must reach the probate court in the original before the period expires.

Competent court. If the deceased last lived abroad, the court of his or her last habitual abode in Germany or the Local Court of Schöneberg in Berlin (Amtsgericht Schöneberg) is often competent (Section 343 FamFG). Details are in the article on the jurisdiction of the probate court where the deceased lived abroad. Whether the option of making the declaration before the court of one’s own state of residence under Article 13 EuErbVO also applies to the contestation of acceptance has not been conclusively settled; anyone who wants to use it should, as a precaution, also make the declaration to the German probate court.

Debts abroad. Mortgages on a holiday property or tax debts in the state of residence often become known late. The decisive question is then whether the heir knew of them when the period expired and whether the misconception was causal. Anyone who does not know who inherits at all or where the estate is located will find guidance in the article on tracing heirs with a foreign connection.

Limiting liability across borders. Estate administration ordered in Germany or German estate insolvency proceedings do not automatically take effect abroad. Whether foreign authorities and courts recognise them and whether separate proceedings are required there must be clarified with a local adviser. Until then it can make sense to secure assets in Germany through an estate curatorship with a foreign connection if the position as heir is still unclear.

Compulsory share and tax. Anyone who contests usually loses, together with the position as heir, the possibility of claiming the compulsory share; exceptions exist, for example under Section 2306 BGB. The article on the compulsory share where assets are abroad explains which claims remain. If inheritance tax has already been assessed, a change to the notice must be clarified with the tax office and, where applicable, the foreign tax authority.

Practical Steps After a Missed Deadline

  1. Record the dates of knowledge and secure documents such as creditors’ letters.
  2. Recalculate the start of the period, including the six-month period under Section 1954 (3) BGB if the deceased lived only abroad or you were abroad when the period began.
  3. Name the ground for contestation concretely: what estate you assumed and which liability was unknown.
  4. Declare in the correct form and in time, allowing a buffer abroad for the consulate, the apostille and dispatch.
  5. Take no further acts of acceptance.
  6. Examine limiting liability in parallel, in particular the duty to file for insolvency under Section 1980 BGB.
  7. Inform successor heirs, above all children, in good time.

Conclusion

Anyone who has missed the disclaimer period is deemed an heir under Section 1943 BGB; there is no restoration of the previous position. The missing of the period can, however, be contested under Section 1956 BGB if there was a relevant mistake, for example about the legal consequences of the lapse of the period or about unknown liabilities. Contestation must reach the probate court in the correct form within six weeks, in the foreign cases of Section 1954 (3) BGB within six months. Where there is no ground for contestation, estate administration, estate insolvency and the plea of insufficient estate remain. Where there is a foreign connection, the law applicable to the succession must also be examined.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still disclaim an inheritance after the six weeks have passed?

Not directly; the inheritance is deemed accepted. If there is a ground for contestation, however, you can contest the missing of the period under Section 1956 BGB; that has the effect of a disclaimer.

Is a mistake about the over-indebtedness of the estate a ground for contestation?

According to the case law of the Federal Court of Justice, over-indebtedness is an essential characteristic of the estate within the meaning of Section 119 (2) BGB. A mistake about the composition of the estate is required, for example about an unknown liability. A mere misvaluation of known assets is in principle not sufficient.

How long do I have for contestation?

Six weeks from knowledge of the ground for contestation; under Section 1954 (3) BGB six months if the deceased had his or her last residence only abroad or you were abroad when the period began. After 30 years, contestation is excluded.

Is a letter or an email to the probate court enough?

No. Contestation must be declared on record at the probate court or in publicly certified form (Sections 1955, 1945 BGB). An authorised representative needs a publicly certified power of attorney.

What can I do if contestation is no longer possible either?

You remain an heir, but you can limit liability to the estate through estate administration, estate insolvency or the plea of insufficient estate under Section 1990 BGB.

Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm, with a focus on international inheritance law, tax law and asset protection in Munich, advise heirs who have missed disclaimer periods, from examining the start of the period and contesting acceptance to limiting liability to the estate in Germany and abroad. Dr. Fiala has published extensively on emigration and asset protection. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.

Do you have questions?

Please do not hesitate to call us for an introductory conversation. I will gladly take the time personally to review your case and give you an estimate of the work involved.

That way, you will already be one step further!

You can reach us by phone at +49 89 / 17 90 900 or by clicking the button:

Call now
Portrait Dr. Fiala

Dr. Johannes Fiala

Your lawyer in Munich is reliable and competent, always by your side.

Recommend us

Found what you were looking for? Do you know someone who could use our support? Feel free to recommend us.