On fiala.de, the article Prior and subsequent heirs with international assets: what applies abroad already covers prior and subsequent inheritance (Vor- und Nacherbschaft) under Sections 2100 et seq. of the German Civil Code (BGB), in which the prior heir (Vorerbe) himself or herself becomes heir to the entire estate or to a share of it. This article is distinct from that: it deals with the subsequent legacy (Nachvermächtnis) under Section 2191 BGB, in which the first beneficiary does not become an heir but remains the legatee of an individual estate asset, which passes to a subsequent beneficiary on the occurrence of a specific event.
Anyone who wants to steer assets across several generations, or to tie individual items in a blended family, without giving the first beneficiary the full position of an heir, comes across the subsequent legacy. With a subsequent legacy in an international estate, additional questions arise: Which law decides when assets are located abroad? Is the construction recognised by foreign registers and banks? And how often is inheritance tax due when the asset passes first to the first beneficiary and later to the subsequent beneficiary? This article places the subsequent legacy in its legal context. The explanations are based on German law (as of October 2026); for the law of other states an adviser admitted there must be consulted.
What Is a Subsequent Legacy? Distinction from Prior and Subsequent Inheritance
Under German law, under Section 1922 BGB the estate passes directly to the heir or heirs by universal succession (Gesamtrechtsnachfolge). A legacy (Vermächtnis) breaks through this principle at specific points: under Section 2174 BGB it merely gives the beneficiary the right to demand delivery of the bequeathed asset from the person burdened. The legatee, unlike the heir, does not directly become the owner but receives a personal claim under the law of obligations (schuldrechtlicher Anspruch) against the person burdened, usually the heir.
If the testator orders that the bequeathed asset is first to pass to a first beneficiary and is to be given to a third party only from a certain point in time or event, there is a prior and subsequent legacy. Under Section 2191 (1) BGB, the first legatee is deemed to be burdened with the subsequent legacy. The subsequent legatee does not acquire a legal position of his or her own against the heir, but a conditional or time-limited claim directly against the prior legatee. For the time between the death and the vesting of the legacy, under Section 2179 BGB the provisions on performance subject to a condition precedent apply accordingly, where a case under Section 2177 or Section 2178 BGB exists.
Under Section 2191 (2) BGB, the provisions on the appointment of prior and subsequent heirs apply accordingly to the prior and subsequent legacy, but only with regard to the questions of interpretation regulated in Section 2102, Section 2106 (1), Section 2107 and Section 2110 (1) BGB, for example on when the event triggering the subsequent legacy occurs. The substantive protective provisions of prior and subsequent inheritance, in particular the restrictions on disposal under Section 2113 BGB, do not apply directly to the subsequent legacy; in this respect the subsequent legatee is limited to claims for damages or surrender against the prior legatee if the latter frustrates performance.
The following overview summarises the most important differences:
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Feature | Prior and subsequent inheritance | Prior and subsequent legacy |
|---|---|---|
| Legal position of the first beneficiary | Heir (prior heir), steps into the whole legal position of the testator | Legatee, receives only a personal claim |
| Subject matter | Whole estate or share of the estate | One or more specific assets |
| Legal position of the subsequent beneficiary | Heir (subsequent heir), receives an expectancy right, claim by operation of law | Legatee, conditional or time-limited claim against the prior legatee |
| Restrictions on disposal | Section 2113 BGB, statutory protection of the subsequent heir | No statutory restriction on disposal of the prior legatee to the same extent |
| Protection in the land register | Subsequent-heir notation under Section 51 of the Land Register Code (GBO) | No separate register provision, only general means of protection |
This distinction is more than a doctrinal subtlety: anyone who in international estate planning wrongly assumes a prior and subsequent inheritance although only a subsequent legacy has been ordered regularly underestimates how weak the position of the subsequent beneficiary actually is until the event triggering the subsequent legacy occurs.
The subsequent legacy is limited in time: a legacy ordered subject to a condition precedent or a starting date becomes ineffective 30 years after the death if the condition or date has not occurred by then (Section 2162 BGB). In principle this also applies to the subsequent legacy. If, however, it falls due on an event in the person of the burdened party, for example on the death of the prior legatee, who is alive at the time of death, it remains effective even after 30 years under Section 2163 (1) no. 1 BGB; where a legal entity is the burdened party, the 30 years apply (Section 2163 (2) BGB; on application to the subsequent legacy, Section 2191 BGB).
What a Subsequent Legacy Is Suited For: Blended Families and Assets Abroad
In practice the subsequent legacy lends itself above all where not the whole estate but only a single, clearly identified asset is to be tied over several stages, for example a holiday property, a foreign account or a business interest. Example from the blended family situation (fictitious): Markus is in a second marriage with Julia and has a son from his first marriage. Julia is to be able to use a holiday apartment in Austria during her lifetime, but the asset is to pass to the son after her death without Julia being able to dispose of it freely as full heir. Julia as prior legatee receives for this a claim to transfer of ownership, which passes to the son as subsequent legatee only on her death; the remaining assets are distributed separately.
For persons entitled to a compulsory share (Pflichtteil) who are themselves provided for only as legatees of a prior and subsequent legacy, Section 2307 BGB is decisive, not Section 2306 BGB, which concerns the legal position of a restricted heir. Under Section 2307 (1) BGB, a person entitled to a compulsory share who has been given a legacy can demand the compulsory share only if he or she disclaims the legacy; if he or she does not, a compulsory share claim exists only to the extent that the value of the legacy falls short of it. In calculating the value, restrictions and burdens of the kind described in Section 2306 BGB are disregarded (Section 2307 (1) sentence 2 BGB). The prior legatee must therefore have the value of the prior legacy credited without deduction for the subsequent legacy; for the drafting this is decisive. Under Section 2307 (2) BGB, the burdened party can set him or her a reasonable period for a declaration; if there is no acceptance in time, the legacy is deemed disclaimed. On enforcing compulsory share claims where assets are abroad, see Compulsory share where assets are abroad: how to enforce claims across borders.
Securing the Subsequent Legacy: Particularities for Real Property
If the subsequent legacy relates to real property, the subsequent legatee, unlike the subsequent heir, lacks a register instrument of his or her own: the subsequent-heir notation under Section 51 GBO is by its wording tailored to prior and subsequent inheritance and does not secure the legal position of a subsequent legatee. At most, a priority notice (Vormerkung) under Section 883 BGB to secure the future claim to transfer of ownership comes into consideration, whose registrability must be examined in the individual case, in particular as to whether and when the prior legatee himself or herself is already entered in the land register as the person entitled. This question has not been answered conclusively and uniformly and should be clarified with a notary before the will is drafted.
For property located abroad this problem becomes more acute: whether a future claim to transfer of ownership from a German subsequent legacy can be made visible at all in the land register or cadastre there is governed by the register and property law of the state where the property is situated. If that state knows neither the subsequent legacy nor a comparable security instrument, the subsequent legatee is left with only a personal claim, without third parties, such as a purchaser in good faith, learning of it. On foreign property in an estate in general, see Bequeathing property abroad: what applies under German inheritance law.
Which Law Applies Where There Is a Foreign Connection?
Within the EU Member States with the exception of Denmark and Ireland, the EU Succession Regulation (EuErbVO, Regulation (EU) No 650/2012) has uniformly determined since 17 August 2015 which law governs a succession: under Article 21 (1) EuErbVO in principle the law of the deceased’s last habitual residence, and under Article 22 EuErbVO, by choice, the law of his or her nationality. Under Article 23 (1) EuErbVO, the entire succession to the estate is subject to this law applicable to the succession (Erbstatut); Article 23 (2) letter e EuErbVO makes clear that the passing of the estate to legatees, including the conditions of acceptance and disclaimer, is also covered. The subsequent legacy therefore in principle falls under the same law as the rest of the succession; the mechanics of the default connecting factor, choice of law and jurisdiction are presented in more depth in International inheritance law when emigrating: how the EuErbVO determines which law applies. Anyone who wants his or her assets arranged under German law should document a corresponding choice of law in the will, as explained in Will where you live abroad: which inheritance law applies to your estate?.
One exception deserves particular attention for the subsequent legacy. Under Article 1 (2) letter k EuErbVO, the nature of rights in rem is excluded from the scope of the Regulation, and under letter l the same applies to the entry of rights in assets in a register, including the requirements and effects of such entry. The German subsequent legacy is purely obligatory in design (Damnationslegat). Some foreign legal systems, in contrast, know a legacy with direct effect in rem that gives the beneficiary ownership without any act of transfer by the burdened party (Vindikationslegat). In Kubicka (vindication legacy under Polish law of succession, property in Germany), the Court of Justice of the EU (CJEU) held that while the nature of rights in rem and registration in the register are not covered by the EuErbVO (Article 1 (2) letters k and l), a notary may not refuse recognition of the direct effect in rem merely because his or her law of property does not know it; adaptation to the law of the state where the property is located is governed by Article 31 EuErbVO (CJEU, judgment of 12 October 2017, C-218/16, Kubicka). The judgment concerns real property and the vindication legacy, not the German subsequent legacy. For the purely obligatory German subsequent legacy, this gives no stronger position abroad than an ordinary personal claim, whose enforcement is governed by the law applicable to performance.
If assets are located in a third state outside the EuErbVO, for example a property, its courts and registers regularly apply their own private international law of succession, which can lead to a split of the estate (Nachlassspaltung): a different law may then apply to the property than to the rest of the assets, which are to be assessed under the EuErbVO. Whether the local law knows an institution such as the subsequent legacy at all, or where appropriate reinterprets it by adaptation to a comparable legal figure of the state where the property is situated, must be assessed in the individual case by an adviser admitted there.
Proof to Banks and Registers: Limits of the European Certificate of Succession
Within the EU Member States, the European Certificate of Succession (ENZ) under Articles 62 et seq. EuErbVO proves the legal position of heirs, executors, estate administrators and legatees. Under Article 63 (1) EuErbVO it is expressly intended for use by legatees with a direct entitlement to the estate. A German subsequent legatee, however, before the event triggering the subsequent legacy occurs, has no direct entitlement in rem, but only a conditional or time-limited personal claim against the prior legatee. Whether and with what content he or she can therefore apply for an ENZ even beforehand, or at least have the restriction on the prior legatee certified in it, has not been conclusively settled and should be coordinated with the competent probate court; which court that is, is explained in Jurisdiction of the probate court where the deceased lived abroad: which court decides on the estate?. Certified copies of the ENZ are valid for only six months under Article 70 (3) EuErbVO and must be extended in good time if needed; outside the EU Member States it has no direct effect in any case.
Inheritance Tax: Two Acquisitions, One Principle of Equal Treatment
For inheritance tax purposes, Section 6 (4) of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetz, ErbStG) provides that subsequent legacies, as well as legacies or charges that fall due only on the death of the burdened party, are treated like subsequent inheritances. In principle, therefore, the same system applies to the subsequent legacy as to prior and subsequent inheritance: the prior legatee first taxes his or her acquisition as his or her own regular acquisition by legacy. If the subsequent legacy later vests, the subsequent legatee must, in accordance with Section 6 (2) sentence 1 ErbStG, in principle tax his or her acquisition as if it came from the prior legatee; on application he or she can instead, under Section 6 (2) sentences 2 to 5 ErbStG, take as a basis his or her relationship to the original testator if that is more favourable, for example where the tax class in relation to the testator is better.
The Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) has confirmed these principles for the second alternative of Section 6 (4) ErbStG, the legacy falling due on the death of the burdened party: for inheritance tax purposes the legatee of such a legacy acquires from the burdened party; if the legatee first appointed drops out before the due date, a legatee appointed in his or her place likewise acquires from the burdened party, not from the person first provided for (Federal Fiscal Court, judgment of 31 August 2021, file no. II R 2/20). In the underlying case a testator had bequeathed a house property to his nephew, whose transfer of ownership could be demanded only after the death of his wife, appointed sole heir; as the nephew died before the wife, his children had to tax the later acquisition as coming from the wife under tax class III (Section 6 (4) ErbStG); even with taxation by reference to the relationship to the testator it would, according to the judgment, have been tax class III. The decision shows how sensitively the tax classification depends on the specific wording and the course of events.
In practice, a subsequent legacy can therefore give rise to two inheritance tax cases, one for the prior legatee and one for the subsequent legatee. If the asset is located abroad or a party resides there, foreign estate or inheritance tax may additionally arise, possibly on both transfers. Such foreign tax can be credited under the conditions of Section 21 ErbStG, to the extent no treaty takes precedence; in the field of inheritance tax, Germany has concluded a double taxation treaty with only a few states. How double taxation can be mitigated is dealt with in detail in Inheritance tax and double taxation treaties: when foreign assets are taxed twice.
Because the inheritance tax treatment in the individual case and its interplay with foreign taxation depend on numerous detailed questions, it is advisable for larger assets to obtain a binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) from the competent tax office under Section 89 (2) of the Fiscal Code (AO) before the final structuring; this presupposes a precisely defined set of facts that has not yet occurred and a special interest because of significant tax effects. Where there is a foreign connection, it should also be examined whether the state concerned knows a comparable ruling possibility that is binding there.
Typical Mistakes in Practice
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Mistake | Risk |
|---|---|
| Confusion with prior and subsequent inheritance | Subsequent legatee is wrongly treated like a subsequent heir, although the statutory protective provisions of Sections 2113 et seq. BGB do not apply to him or her |
| No security for real property | Without a priority notice or a comparable instrument, the subsequent legatee is unprotected against dispositions by the prior legatee |
| Foreign property included without local review | Unclear whether the subsequent legacy can be implemented at all in the state where the property is situated or is reinterpreted there |
| Choice of law omitted | On a move, a foreign law of succession can unnoticed decide on the subsequent legacy |
| Compulsory share law overlooked | A prior legatee entitled to a compulsory share can disclaim under Section 2307 BGB and demand the compulsory share if the legacy is unfavourable for him or her |
| Double taxation not allowed for | Two tax cases in Germany and a possible additional tax abroad are not taken into account in liquidity planning |
| ENZ applied for without reflection | Without coordination with the probate court, it remains open whether and how the restriction of the subsequent legacy is shown in it |
Conclusion
The subsequent legacy under Section 2191 BGB is a leaner but also less strongly protected structuring instrument than prior and subsequent inheritance: it is suited to individual assets instead of the whole estate, but gives the subsequent beneficiary only a personal claim, not a position as heir. In an international estate there are added: the question of the applicable law, the limited effect of the European Certificate of Succession for a person with only a personal entitlement, security problems for foreign property and the tax equation with subsequent inheritance under Section 6 (4) ErbStG, which can lead to a double burden where assets are abroad. Anyone who wants to order a subsequent legacy with a foreign connection should examine these points before drawing up the will and, where there is tax uncertainty, obtain a binding ruling.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the difference between a subsequent legacy and a subsequent inheritance?
With a subsequent legacy, the first beneficiary does not become an heir but the legatee of an individual asset; the subsequent beneficiary receives only a personal claim against him or her. With subsequent inheritance, the prior heir becomes heir to the entire estate or to a share, and the subsequent heir receives that position as heir by operation of law.
Does a German subsequent legacy automatically apply abroad?
No. Within the EU the EuErbVO determines the applicable law of succession, which in principle also applies to legacies. For third states and in particular for property, the state where the property is situated can apply its own law and may not know the institution at all, or only in a limited way.
Is inheritance tax due twice on a subsequent legacy?
Under German law, in principle yes: Section 6 (4) ErbStG treats the subsequent legacy like subsequent inheritance, so that inheritance tax can arise both for the prior legatee and for the subsequent legatee. The subsequent legatee can apply to be taxed by reference to his or her relationship to the original testator if that is more favourable.
Can a subsequent legacy be secured in the land register?
The subsequent-heir notation under Section 51 GBO applies to prior and subsequent inheritance, not to the subsequent legacy. At most, a priority notice to secure the future claim to transfer of ownership comes into consideration; whether and under what conditions this is possible should be clarified in advance with a notary.
What happens if a person entitled to a compulsory share is appointed as prior legatee?
He or she can disclaim the legacy under Section 2307 BGB and demand the compulsory share instead. If he or she accepts it, a further compulsory share claim exists only to the extent that the value of the legacy falls short of it.
Can I stipulate that German law applies to my subsequent legacy if I live abroad?
As a German national you can choose the law of your nationality under Article 22 EuErbVO for your entire estate, which also covers an ordered subsequent legacy. The choice of law should be declared expressly in the disposition upon death.
Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala has published extensively on inheritance and tax law with a foreign connection and advises you on structuring legacies and subsequent legacies with assets abroad, on coordination with foreign advisers and on the inheritance tax consequences. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your specific case in an initial consultation.