German Exit Tax on Individual Business Assets: Exit Taxation Under Section 4 EStG

German Exit Tax on Individual Business Assets: Exit Taxation Under Section 4 EStG

Exit Tax on Individual Business Assets

The exit tax on individual business assets (Wegzugsteuer bei betrieblichen Einzelwirtschaftsgütern, also called Entstrickung, “unwinding” of German taxing rights) does not hit GmbH shareholders but above all sole proprietors, freelancers and partners in partnerships (Mitunternehmerschaften) who move individual assets of their business, such as a machine, a patent or a plot of land, abroad or allocate them to a foreign permanent establishment. Unlike the better-known exit tax on GmbH shares, a mere change of the person’s residence is not enough here: what matters is whether Germany thereby loses or restricts its right to tax the hidden reserves (stille Reserven) of a specific asset. Anyone who overlooks this risks an immediate tax charge, independent of any actual inflow of cash, on increases in value that have built up in the business over years.

On fiala.de, the article Exit tax on GmbH shareholdings already covers the exit tax under Section 6 of the Foreign Tax Act (Außensteuergesetz, AStG), which concerns exclusively a shareholder’s personal shares in a corporation when he or she moves their residence abroad. This article deals with the clearly distinct exit taxation of individual business assets under Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. of the Income Tax Act (Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG), where these assets of a sole proprietorship or partnership are moved abroad or allocated to a foreign permanent establishment. Both provisions can become relevant at the same time in practice, for example where an entrepreneur is both a shareholder of a GmbH and runs a sole proprietorship, but they must be kept strictly apart in law. Exit taxation at the level of a corporation itself under Section 12 of the Corporate Income Tax Act (KStG), in particular for transfers of functions and transfer pricing questions under Section 1 AStG, is dealt with in depth in the article Exit taxation of business assets; this article deliberately concentrates on the perspective of sole proprietors, freelancers and partnerships.

This article classifies the deemed withdrawal under Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. EStG, explains the balancing item under Section 4g EStG, distinguishes the exit taxation of individual assets from that of the entire business under Section 16 (3a) EStG, and shows what sole proprietors and partners should look out for when planning a move abroad.

The Three Exit Taxes at a Glance: Who Falls Under Which Provision

In practice the various exit and unwinding provisions are often mixed up. The following overview classifies the three most important constellations:

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Feature Section 6 AStG Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. EStG Section 16 (3a) EStG
Person affected Natural person as shareholder of a corporation Sole proprietor or partner in a partnership Sole proprietor or partner (entire business/part of a business)
Object of taxation Shares within the meaning of Section 17 EStG (at least 1 percent) Individual asset of the business assets All assets of a business or part of a business
Trigger End of the person’s unlimited tax liability Exclusion or restriction of the German right to tax an asset Exclusion or restriction of the right to tax for the entire business/part of a business
Legal consequence Deemed sale of the shares at fair market value Deemed withdrawal at fair market value (current profit) Deemed cessation of business at fair market value
Deferral of payment Payment in instalments over 7 years, EU/EEA and third countries alike (since the ATAD Implementation Act 2021) Balancing item over 5 years under Section 4g EStG, EU/EEA only Payment in instalments over 5 years under Section 36 (5) EStG, EU/EEA only

This comparison shows the central difference: while since 2022 the legislator has harmonised the deferral rules for GmbH shares for EU/EEA states and third countries, the older, narrower rule continues to apply to the exit taxation of individual assets and to a complete cessation of business: deferral of payment is possible only if the asset is allocated to business assets in another EU or EEA member state. Anyone who relocates to a third country outside the EU/EEA, for example to Switzerland, Serbia, the United Arab Emirates or the USA, must in principle pay tax on the exit gain immediately and in full.

The Deemed Withdrawal Under Section 4 (1) Sentences 3 et seq. EStG: How Exit Taxation of Individual Assets Works

The basic rule on the exit taxation of individual assets is set out in Section 4 (1) sentence 3 EStG: if the right of the Federal Republic of Germany to tax the gain from the sale or use of an asset is excluded or restricted, this is treated as a withdrawal for non-business purposes. Sentence 4 spells out the practically most important case: an exclusion or restriction of the right to tax exists in particular where an asset that was previously attributable to a domestic permanent establishment is in future attributable to a foreign permanent establishment of the same taxpayer. The legal consequence is the same as for an actual withdrawal: the asset is valued at fair market value (gemeiner Wert), the difference from the book value is taxable as profit, irrespective of whether any money actually flows in.

This provision was introduced in its present basic structure by the SEStEG of 7 December 2006, after the “theory of final withdrawal” advocated by the tax administration had previously pursued the same economic purpose. The Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof, BFH) removed the basis of this judge-made construct by judgment of 17 July 2008 (I R 77/06): according to it, the mere transfer of an asset to a foreign permanent establishment exempt under a double taxation treaty (DBA) did not in itself yet establish a definitive loss of the German right to tax. The legislator reacted with the Annual Tax Act 2010 (Jahressteuergesetz 2010), which under Section 52 (8b) EStG retroactively extended the application of Section 4 (1) sentence 3 EStG also to financial years ending before 1 January 2006 with DBA exemption. By judgment of 26 March 2025 (I R 5/24, formerly I R 99/15), the BFH confirmed this genuine retroactivity as constitutional and, with reference to the ECJ judgment in Verder LabTec (21 May 2015, C-657/13), also regarded taxation in instalments via a multi-year memorandum item as unobjectionable under EU law.

Not every relocation requires active conduct by the taxpayer. On passive exit taxation, the BFH took a position in two judgments of 19 November 2025 (published on 9 April 2026). In case I R 41/22 (double taxation treaty with Spain) it clarified that changes in the treaty position, without any action by the taxpayer, can also lead to exit taxation. In case I R 6/23 (double taxation treaty with Australia of 2015, applicable from 2017), by contrast, it denied exit taxation because neither an exclusion nor a restriction of the German right to tax had occurred. The requirements are therefore narrow: a new treaty does not automatically lead to exit taxation. Anyone who holds assets abroad should nevertheless have existing foreign structures reviewed regularly for whether a change in a treaty affects the German right to tax.

Sole Proprietorship, Freelancers and Partnerships: Who Is Affected in Which Constellation?

Exit taxation under Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. EStG affects not only commercial sole proprietors but in principle everyone who earns business-type income and holds assets in business assets, including freelancers who relocate their business abroad, such as doctors, architects or tax advisers with their own practice. For them, besides tangible fixed assets, intangible assets such as the patient or client base and the practice value (goodwill) are among the items in which hidden reserves can build up over years.

For a partnership (Mitunternehmerschaft), a further distinction must be made as to whose assets are affected. Assets in the joint partnership assets (Gesamthandsvermögen) are attributed for tax purposes to the partners proportionately; if the partnership moves such an asset to a foreign permanent establishment, this can trigger exit taxation proportionately for each partner. In addition there are special business assets (Sonderbetriebsvermögen): assets that an individual partner makes available to the partnership for use, for example a plot of land owned by him or her and let to the partnership. Whether a shift in the German right to tax arises there at all from the mere change of residence of the partner concerned depends decisively on how the relevant double taxation treaty allocates the income from the partnership to the state of the permanent establishment. These allocation questions are often complex in the individual case; the article Partnership and emigration: tax consequences for partners in a KG, OHG and GbR goes into this partner-related perspective.

When Does German Taxing Authority Remain? The Domestic Permanent Establishment

Exit taxation does not apply automatically merely because the entrepreneur moves his or her own private residence abroad. What matters is whether the business assets remain allocated to a domestic permanent establishment. Under Section 12 sentence 1 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO), a permanent establishment is any fixed place of business or facility that serves the activity of the enterprise; a mere postal address is not sufficient. On the feature of the fixed place of business, the BFH worked out in its judgment of 7 June 2023 (I R 47/20) that the taxpayer must have more than temporary power of disposal over the facility. By letter of 18 June 2026, the Federal Ministry of Finance recast its administrative principles on the concept of the permanent establishment and replaced the principles of 1999 in that respect; according to them, a temporal stability of at least six months is regularly required.

If an entrepreneur continues his or her business, such as a law office, a practice or a trading business, in Germany with employed staff and its own management, and merely moves abroad personally, the domestic permanent establishment generally continues to exist; exit taxation is then in principle ruled out. The position is different if the actual management is in fact exercised from abroad while only a formal shell remains in Germany: the tax administration examines this on the basis of travel activity, decision-making processes and the actual place of management. The article Management abroad: the permanent establishment risk deals with this distinction in depth.

The Balancing Item Under Section 4g EStG: Deferral of Payment Over Five Years, but Only Within the EU/EEA

If an individual asset is allocated to a permanent establishment in another EU or EEA member state, the resulting tax does not have to be paid immediately in full. Under Section 4g EStG, on an irrevocable application the taxpayer can form a balancing item (Ausgleichsposten) in the amount of the difference between the book value and the fair market value to be applied. This balancing item is released, increasing profit, by one fifth in each case in the financial year of its formation and in the four following financial years; economically this corresponds to an interest-free spreading of the tax payment over five years. A precondition is always that the restriction of the German right to tax occurs in favour of a state within the meaning of Section 36 (5) sentence 1 EStG, that is, an EU or EEA member state that provides mutual assistance in tax assessment and recovery corresponding to or comparable with the EU Mutual Assistance Directive. This mechanism is not available for assets allocated to a permanent establishment in a third country.

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Point in time Release of the balancing item
Financial year of formation 1/5 increasing profit
1st following year 1/5 increasing profit
2nd following year 1/5 increasing profit
3rd following year 1/5 increasing profit
4th following year 1/5 increasing profit
Early event (e.g. sale of the asset, transfer to a non-privileged state, breach of the notification duty) Complete, immediate release

This five-year spreading via the balancing item thus differs clearly from the seven-year payment in instalments under Section 6 (4) AStG that has applied to GmbH shares since 2022: it is shorter, it requires an irrevocable application, and, unlike the payment in instalments for GmbH shares, which since the ATAD Implementation Act of 25 June 2021 (applicable from 2022) is also granted on a move to third countries, it is available exclusively on an allocation within the EU/EEA. That applies only to Section 6 AStG: for withdrawal taxation under Section 16 (3a) EStG, five annual instalments apply (Section 36 (5) EStG), likewise only on relocation to the EU/EEA. In addition, the taxpayer is obliged to notify the tax authority of the withdrawal and certain events without delay; if these notification, record-keeping or cooperation duties are breached, the balancing item is likewise released in full.

The Special Case of a Complete Cessation of Business: Section 16 (3a) EStG

The exit taxation of individual assets is to be distinguished from the case where the German right to tax is excluded or restricted with respect to all assets of an entire business or part of a business, for example because the entrepreneur moves his or her whole business with all essential assets abroad. For this case, Section 16 (3a) EStG fictitiously assumes a cessation of business. The economic difference from the exit taxation of an individual asset lies above all in two points: first, on application under Section 36 (5) EStG the tax attributable to it can be paid in equal annual instalments over five years, under the same EU/EEA requirements as for the balancing item under Section 4g EStG, but as a rule only against security. Second, a cessation gain under Section 16 EStG, to the extent it is attributable to a natural person as sole proprietor or as directly participating partner, in principle does not form part of the trade earnings; for a partnership, this exception for the share attributable to natural persons follows from Section 7 sentence 2 of the Trade Tax Act (Gewerbesteuergesetz, GewStG). By contrast, the deemed withdrawal of an individual asset under Section 4 (1) sentence 3 EStG is to be treated systematically as current profit and, unlike a cessation of business, would therefore in principle also be subject to trade tax in the case of a commercial business. This classification has not been conclusively settled by the highest courts in the literature and, particularly for larger amounts, should be secured in the individual case by a binding ruling.

Return to Germany: What Happens to Assets That Have Already Been Unwound?

Unlike the exit tax on GmbH shares, where Section 6 (3) AStG provides a genuine return rule with retroactive lapse of the tax claim, the exit taxation of individual assets knows no comparable automatic reversal. If an asset previously unwound later returns to Germany, for example because the foreign permanent establishment is closed, and thereby re-establishes the German right to tax, this is equivalent to a contribution (Section 4 (1) sentence 8 EStG). The asset is to be recognised at fair market value; if the other state has taxed because of the exclusion or restriction of its right to tax, the value that this state uses as the basis for taxation applies, at most the fair market value (Section 6 (1) no. 5a EStG). The exit tax already incurred on the increase in value up to the time of the relocation is not retroactively cancelled as a result; a balancing item under Section 4g EStG that has not yet been fully released continues regularly or, on certain events, becomes due early in full. Anyone who considers a later relocation back to be likely should plan in advance for this departure from the return rule for GmbH shares.

Planning Options Before the Move

The system described gives rise to several starting points for practice, each of which should be examined in good time before the planned move:

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Starting point Effect
Retain a domestic permanent establishment with staff and management Exit taxation in principle does not apply, as no shift of the right to tax occurs
Relocate only individual assets instead of the entire business Balancing item under Section 4g EStG instead of immediate full taxation, provided the target state is in the EU/EEA
Contribution of business assets to a corporation before the move (Section 20 of the Reorganisation Tax Act, UmwStG) Book-value treatment only under the conditions of Section 20 UmwStG; the shares received are subject to a seven-year blocking period (Section 22 UmwStG), and a sale or a move with deemed realisation during that period leads to subsequent taxation of the hidden reserves. Thereafter the tax question under Section 6 AStG arises for the shares then held, including its return rule
Transfer to a successor remaining in Germany before the move On a transfer of the business or part of a business free of charge, the book values are continued (Section 6 (3) EStG); the hidden reserves remain latently subject to tax with the successor and are taxed there when they are later uncovered. The person moving away has no exit gain
Documentation of the actual management and of the permanent establishment structure Makes it easier to show the tax office that there is no shift of the right to tax

If, within such an arrangement, a property held in business assets is also contributed to a corporation before the move, separate deadlines and requirements have to be observed; the article Contributing property to a GmbH before emigrating classifies this separately.

Example (purely hypothetical, for illustration): A physiotherapist runs her practice as a sole proprietor and plans a permanent move to Portugal. If she continues the practice unchanged in Germany with employed staff and moves only her private life abroad, the permanent establishment in this entirely fictitious example remains in Germany; exit taxation should be ruled out. If, on the other hand, she transfers the practice equipment and patient base completely to a new practice in Portugal and closes the German practice, there is exit taxation of the entire business under Section 16 (3a) EStG with uncovering of all hidden reserves.

The Note on the Binding Ruling

The distinction between a continuing domestic permanent establishment, exit taxation of individual assets and a complete cessation of business depends on a large number of factual circumstances which often can be finally assessed only afterwards, in a later tax audit. Because the legal position in the cross-border context keeps changing, for example through new double taxation treaties, passive exit taxation and the recast administrative view of the concept of the permanent establishment, entrepreneurs should, before finally implementing a move with relevant business assets, obtain a binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) from the competent tax office under Section 89 (2) AO, provided the facts have not yet occurred and there is a particular interest in legal certainty because of the tax effects. Where a foreign element is involved, it should additionally be examined whether a comparable advance binding ruling is also possible in the target state, in order to identify contradictions between the two legal systems early. The article Binding ruling before emigrating explains the requirements, competence and costs of this instrument.

Conclusion

The exit tax on individual business assets must be clearly distinguished from the exit tax on GmbH shares under Section 6 AStG: while the latter is linked to the shareholder’s personal change of residence, Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. EStG looks solely at whether Germany loses or restricts the right to tax a specific asset, irrespective of whether the entrepreneur moves personally. Anyone who maintains the domestic permanent establishment with substance can regularly avoid exit taxation; anyone who allocates individual assets to an EU/EEA permanent establishment can spread the tax over five years via the balancing item under Section 4g EStG; anyone who relocates to a third country or closes the entire business faces fundamentally different legal consequences. In view of the recast administrative view of the concept of the permanent establishment and the case law on passive exit taxation, early planning, secured by a binding ruling where in doubt, is indispensable.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does the exit tax under Section 6 AStG also apply to sole proprietors?

No. Section 6 AStG concerns exclusively shares in corporations within the meaning of Section 17 EStG. For sole proprietors and partners, the exit taxation rule of Section 4 (1) sentences 3 et seq. EStG applies instead or, where the entire business is relocated, Section 16 (3a) EStG.

Does a private change of residence abroad already trigger exit taxation?

Not automatically. What matters is whether the move also relocates business assets or the actual management in such a way that Germany loses the right to tax them. If a domestic permanent establishment with staff and management remains, the private change of residence can in itself be harmless for tax purposes.

Can I defer the exit tax if I move to Switzerland, Serbia or the USA?

No, at least not under Section 4g EStG or Section 36 (5) EStG. Both deferral mechanisms apply only if the asset is allocated to a permanent establishment in another EU or EEA member state. On relocation to a third country the tax in principle becomes due immediately in full.

What happens if I later bring an asset that was previously unwound back to Germany?

The tax already incurred is not retroactively cancelled as a result; unlike the return rule for GmbH shares under Section 6 (3) AStG, there is no general reversal. The return regularly leads to a contribution at the value that will apply in future; a balancing item not yet released continues regularly.

Do I have to report the exit taxation to the tax office?

Yes. Anyone who has formed a balancing item under Section 4g EStG must notify the withdrawal and later events without delay and keep a continuing record. Irrespective of this, there is the general duty to state the facts completely in the tax return.

Is the exit gain subject to the favourable partial income method as with GmbH shares?

In principle no. The partial income method (Teileinkünfteverfahren) under Section 3 no. 40 EStG applies to shares in corporations. If a machine, a patent or a plot of land is unwound, the full gain is subject to income tax; a partial exemption comes into question only if the asset unwound is itself a shareholding in a corporation held in business assets.

Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm have published extensively on international tax and company law and support sole proprietors, freelancers and partners in partnerships in planning a move abroad, from assessing the exit taxation risks and structuring a domestic permanent establishment to coordination with foreign advisers. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your personal situation in an initial consultation.

Do you have questions?

Please do not hesitate to call us for an introductory conversation. I will gladly take the time personally to review your case and give you an estimate of the work involved.

That way, you will already be one step further!

You can reach us by phone at +49 89 / 17 90 900 or by clicking the button:

Call now
Portrait Dr. Fiala

Dr. Johannes Fiala

Your lawyer in Munich is reliable and competent, always by your side.

Recommend us

Found what you were looking for? Do you know someone who could use our support? Feel free to recommend us.