On fiala.de, the article Family foundation as asset protection for emigrants already covers the foundation as an ownerless legal-entity pool of assets under Sections 80 et seq. of the German Civil Code (BGB). This article concerns a different, equally widespread structure: the family office as a corporate asset management company, usually a GmbH or a GmbH & Co. KG as a holding company, in which the family remains a shareholder rather than finally making the assets independent as with a foundation. This corporate character gives rise, on a move abroad, to different risks than with the foundation.
Anyone who pools family assets in a company of their own often calls this a family office. What is usually meant is not a legal form of its own but an asset management GmbH or a holding company with management functions that holds the family’s participations, real estate and financial investments. If the shareholder family also plans a move abroad, the family office structure meets, on that move, a dense web of tax rules that look harmless in isolation but in combination can lead to a considerable, partly permanent burden. This article puts the main risks in context: the exit tax on the shares, the permanent establishment risk when the place of management is moved, the distinction between asset management and trade or business status, controlled foreign company taxation (Hinzurechnungsbesteuerung) for foreign intermediate companies, and the tax group risk.
What Makes a Family Office Structure Legally
Legally, a family office structure is usually one or more of the following variants:
- an asset management GmbH that holds securities, participations or real estate in its own name,
- a holding GmbH & Co. KG in which a GmbH as general partner (Komplementärin) manages the business and the family members participate as limited partners (Kommanditisten),
- a multi-tier structure of parent and subsidiary companies, for example to separate the operating business from pure administrative assets.
What all variants have in common is that, unlike with the foundation, the family remains a shareholder and retains direct influence through the shareholders’ meeting, management or an advisory board. This continuing link between family and assets is the starting point for the following risks: where the foundation is regularly unaffected when the founder leaves, the family office GmbH remains closely tied to the emigrating persons through the shareholding, management and, where applicable, a tax group.
Risk 1: Exit Tax on the GmbH Shares under Section 6 AStG
If a shareholder moves his or her residence or habitual abode abroad and unlimited income tax liability thereby ends, Section 6 of the Foreign Tax Act (Außensteuergesetz, AStG) assumes a sale at fair market value (gemeiner Wert) for shares in corporations within the meaning of Section 17 of the Income Tax Act (Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG). In the case of a family office GmbH this directly affects the shareholders themselves, whose shares are held as private assets. Section 6 AStG applies to shares in corporations, not to interests in a GmbH & Co. KG. For a holding GmbH & Co. KG, the consequences of departure depend on the character of the income (commercial through classification or asset management) and on the rules on exit taxation (Entstrickung) (Section 4 (1) sentence 3 EStG); the departure case must be examined separately here.
The provision applies if the shareholder held at least one percent within the last five years before leaving and was subject to unlimited income tax liability in Germany for a total of at least seven years in the twelve years before the end of unlimited tax liability. In the case of a family office GmbH with several generations as shareholders, this must be examined separately for each shareholder; if only part of the family emigrates, the exit tax affects only that part.
Because no actual sale takes place and therefore no sale price is received, a tax burden arises on an unrealised gain (so-called dry income). On application, the law provides for interest-free payment in seven equal annual instalments, although the tax authorities may require security. If the shareholder returns to Germany within seven years and certain further requirements are met, the tax claim can lapse retroactively. The deadlines, evidence and notification duties to be observed in detail are explained in depth in the article Exit tax on GmbH shareholdings; the details of the seven-year instalment payments are covered in the article Exit tax: payment in instalments over seven years.
Risk 2: Moving the Place of Management as a Permanent Establishment and Exit Taxation Risk
A separate risk, to be distinguished from the shareholders’ exit tax, arises at the level of the company itself if the managing director or directors of the family office GmbH emigrate too and in future run the day-to-day business from the new residence abroad.
Under Section 10 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO), the place of management (Geschäftsleitung) is the centre of business control, that is, the place where the decisions essential for day-to-day business are actually made. The actual circumstances are what counts, not the formal statement in the articles of association. Under Section 12 sentence 2 no. 1 AO, the place of management by itself already establishes a permanent establishment. If the actual management of a family office GmbH moves permanently to the new residence of the management abroad, a permanent establishment or even full tax residence under the law of the destination state can arise there, regardless of the fact that the registered office remains entered in the German commercial register.
The German registered office alone does not end the unlimited corporate income tax liability of the GmbH, because Section 1 (1) no. 1 of the Corporate Income Tax Act (Körperschaftsteuergesetz, KStG) already makes a domestic registered office sufficient. In practice this often results in dual residence: the GmbH remains subject to unlimited tax liability under German law but may at the same time be treated as resident under the law of the destination state. A relevant double taxation treaty regularly resolves such cases through a tie-breaker rule on the place of effective management, which can allocate the right to tax wholly or partly to the other state. If German taxing rights over the company’s assets are thereby excluded or restricted, Section 12 (1) KStG orders exit taxation at fair market value. If the company moves its management and registered office completely abroad and unlimited corporate income tax liability thereby ceases altogether, this exit taxation rule ultimately covers all the company’s assets, economically comparable to the disclosure of all hidden reserves; a separate liquidation of the company is not required for this. Particularly affected in practice are intangible values such as self-created know-how or trademark rights, whose attribution is often disputed in the individual case. Which structures can limit this permanent establishment risk is shown in detail in the article Management abroad: the permanent establishment risk.
Risk 3: Distinction Between Asset Management and Trade or Business Status in Mixed Structures
A point underestimated in practice concerns the question of whether the family office structure can count as purely asset-managing at all. A strict distinction by legal form is needed here.
For a GmbH, the distinction does not arise in practice: under Section 8 (2) KStG, all income of corporations subject to unlimited tax liability is always treated as income from a trade or business; this is a fiction of commercial status by virtue of the legal form. An asset management GmbH is therefore in principle also subject to trade tax, even if it merely manages its own investment assets or its own real estate. Relief exists only for companies that manage exclusively their own real estate (and, in addition, their own investment assets): on application they can claim the extended reduction under Section 9 no. 1 sentence 2 of the Trade Tax Act (Gewerbesteuergesetz, GewStG), whereby the trade income attributable to the property management ultimately remains free of trade tax. This reduction is, however, subject to a strict exclusivity requirement; even a minor commercial side activity can cause it to lapse entirely.
The position is different for a holding in the legal form of a GmbH & Co. KG, as is often chosen for family office structures. If such a partnership carries on a commercial activity in addition to asset management, Section 15 (3) no. 1 EStG treats the entire activity as a trade or business, the so-called taint or infection effect. If, on the other hand, only a corporation is the personally liable partner and only it or non-partners are authorised to manage the business, Section 15 (3) no. 2 EStG applies and the partnership is commercially characterised (gewerblich geprägt), counting as commercial by virtue of that characterisation alone, even if it merely manages assets. “Pure” asset management without trade tax relevance can therefore hardly be achieved with the classic general-partner-GmbH structure. Because a move is often the occasion for reorganising the structure, any restructuring should be examined in advance for its trade tax consequences.
Risk 4: Controlled Foreign Company Taxation When the Foreign Structure Becomes an Intermediate Company
Not infrequently the emigrated family sets up, at the new residence or in a third country, a new foreign holding or management company that thenceforth holds the family assets. If, for example, the younger generation remains subject to unlimited income tax liability in Germany and holds a controlling stake in this foreign company, controlled foreign company taxation under Sections 7 et seq. AStG comes into view.
If persons subject to unlimited tax liability, alone or together with related persons within the meaning of Section 1 (2) AStG, control more than half of the voting rights, the shares in the nominal capital or the entitlement to profit or liquidation proceeds of a foreign company with neither registered office nor place of management in Germany, its income is attributed proportionately to the controlling persons as if they had earned the income themselves. A precondition is that the company counts as an intermediate company (Zwischengesellschaft) within the meaning of Section 8 AStG: it must earn income that does not fall under one of the groups of active activities exhaustively listed in Section 8 (1) AStG, for example pure investment income, dividends or capital gains from participations, as is typical of a pure asset management company, and this income must be low-taxed, that is, under Section 8 (5) AStG burdened with income tax of less than 15 percent. For intermediate income of an investment nature, that is, precisely in the case of a pure asset management company, control is not necessary: a holding of at least 10 percent of the voting rights or shares, alone or together with related persons, suffices provided the income is low-taxed (Section 13 (1) AStG; control, by contrast, is governed by Section 7 (2) AStG). This hits the family office directly.
Anyone who moves away but retains substantial economic interests in Germany and lives in a low-tax country may, as a German national who was subject to unlimited tax liability for at least five of the ten years before leaving, remain subject to extended limited income tax liability for ten years under Section 2 AStG (residence in a low-tax jurisdiction or in no state, substantial economic interests in Germany).
For a family office structure that is deliberately newly set up as low-taxing after the move, it is therefore by no means automatically ensured that future income is withdrawn from German taxation as long as family members subject to unlimited tax liability still hold a controlling stake. How the requirements can be examined in detail and which exceptions apply, for example for proven economic activity in the EU/EEA under Section 8 (2) AStG, is set out in the article Controlled foreign company taxation for a foreign company.
Risk 5: Tax Group and the Departure of the Controlling Parent
If the family office structure has a multi-tier set-up and is organised as a corporate income tax group (Organschaft) under Section 14 KStG through a profit and loss transfer agreement, a move can endanger this structure, even though since the 2012 reform no residence requirement applies to the controlling parent (Organträger) itself. Under Section 14 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 KStG, what is decisive is rather that the participation that provides the financial integration of the subsidiary (Organgesellschaft) is continuously attributable to a domestic permanent establishment of the controlling parent within the meaning of Section 12 AO.
If the shareholder acting as controlling parent, for example a natural person with a sole proprietorship or a partnership as a management holding, moves abroad together with the actual management, it must be examined whether the participation in the subsidiary can still be attributed to a domestic permanent establishment or is to be attributed to the new foreign centre of life. If the domestic attribution lapses, the tax group ends; if this falls below the five-year minimum term, it can, under Section 14 (1) sentence 1 no. 3 KStG, even lapse retroactively for the entire term of the agreement, with interest on back payments for all assessments concerned. That even a purely managing holding partnership without its own operating business can qualify as a controlling parent was confirmed by the Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof) in its judgment of 27 November 2024 (I R 23/21); this increases the practical importance of this constellation for family office structures. Details and possible structures are covered in the article Tax group: termination on departure of the controlling parent.
Distinction from the Family Foundation
Anyone considering setting up a family foundation instead of the corporate family office structure should know the fundamental difference: because a foundation has neither shares nor shareholders, the founder’s departure comes to nothing as far as Section 6 AStG is concerned, which attaches to shares within the meaning of Section 17 EStG. In return, the foundation is subject to the substitute inheritance tax (Erbersatzsteuer) arising every 30 years, which a family office GmbH does not know, and a foreign foundation or trust is subject to separate attribution taxation under Section 15 AStG, which stands alongside controlled foreign company taxation under Sections 7 et seq. AStG. Which structure fits depends on whether the family wants to give up direct ownership or whether continuing corporate control matters more to it. The article Family foundation as asset protection for emigrants examines this alternative in more depth.
Structuring Approaches Before Leaving
The following overview summarises where each risk attaches and where a more detailed review leads.
← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen
| Risk | Point of attachment | Possible response |
|---|---|---|
| Exit tax on shares (Section 6 AStG) | Shareholder, not company | Prepare valuation, apply for payment in instalments, consider return option |
| Permanent establishment risk (Sections 10, 12 AO, Section 12 KStG) | Place of actual management | Deliberately anchor management, decision-making and documentation in Germany, or price in the consequences of a relocation |
| Commercial status/infection (Section 8 (2) KStG, Section 15 (3) EStG) | Legal form and mix of activities | Review choice of legal form and holding structure before leaving |
| Controlled foreign company taxation (Sections 7 et seq. AStG) | Control by persons who remain subject to unlimited tax liability; for investment-type income at least 10 percent suffices (Section 13 AStG) | Clarify circle of shareholders and control relationships after leaving |
| Tax group risk (Section 14 KStG) | Attribution of the participation to a domestic permanent establishment | Secure the permanent establishment structure of the controlling parent before leaving or end the tax group in good time |
A holding structure that is set up only shortly before leaving and solely to avoid the exit tax carries its own risks, such as a possible review for abuse or newly triggered gift tax on the contribution. When a holding structure actually protects against exit taxation is explained in the article Setting up a holding structure before emigrating.
Illustrative Example
The following example is entirely fictitious and serves solely as an illustration; it describes no real case and no real person.
An entrepreneurial family holds its participations and real estate through an asset management GmbH whose shares belong in equal parts to the parents and two adult children. The parents move their residence permanently to Portugal; the mother remains sole managing director and in future carries out the day-to-day business predominantly from there; one child remains subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany. In this entirely fictitious example the parents would first have to have the requirements of Section 6 AStG examined for their own shares. Independently of that, the question arises whether, through management from Portugal, the place of actual management of the GmbH moves there and a permanent establishment or exit taxation risk under Section 12 KStG arises. If the GmbH remained unchanged as a German company with the child, still subject to unlimited tax liability, holding a controlling stake, controlled foreign company taxation under Sections 7 et seq. AStG would not apply for lack of a foreign intermediate company; it could be different if the family had instead set up a new company in the destination state.
Binding Ruling Instead of Speculation
The risks above intervene in a web of national tax law, the Fiscal Code and, where applicable, a double taxation treaty, whose interplay, for example in determining the place of actual management, is not always clear in the individual case and can change with case law. Anyone who wants legal certainty for a specifically planned structure before leaving can apply to the competent tax office for a binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) under Section 89 (2) AO. Where there is a foreign connection, it should also be examined whether the destination state knows a comparable information or ruling procedure, so that both sides of the structure are assessed in coordination. The fee for this under Section 89 (3) to (7) AO is measured by the value of the subject matter and, for the risks described here, is regularly considerably lower than a subsequently assessed back payment of tax including interest. What requirements, deadlines and costs are involved in detail is set out in the article Binding ruling before emigration.
Conclusion
A family office structure in the form of an asset management GmbH or a holding GmbH & Co. KG remains closely tied through the shareholding to the persons who support it; precisely this makes it vulnerable on a move abroad at several independent points: the exit tax on the shares, the permanent establishment and exit taxation risk when management is relocated, the trade tax treatment depending on legal form, controlled foreign company taxation where family members who remained in Germany continue to control it, and the continuation of any tax group. None of these risks disappears automatically because the family physically emigrates; anyone who puts such a structure in order before leaving should have all five levels examined together.
Frequently Asked Questions About the Family Office Structure When Moving Abroad
Does merely setting up a family office GmbH before leaving trigger the exit tax?
No. Section 6 AStG attaches to the end of the shareholder’s unlimited tax liability, not to the setting up of the company. A contribution of shares to a new holding shortly before leaving can, however, have its own gift tax or reorganisation tax consequences, which must be examined separately.
Is it enough if only the management, but not the registered office of the GmbH, is moved abroad?
Legally the GmbH remains subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany because of the domestic registered office (Section 1 (1) no. 1 KStG). That does not rule out, however, that through the relocated management it additionally becomes resident in the destination state, with the consequence of possible double taxation that must be resolved through a double taxation treaty.
Does controlled foreign company taxation also affect family offices that are newly set up entirely abroad?
It requires that the foreign company is controlled by persons subject to unlimited tax liability. If the whole family emigrates and unlimited tax liability ends completely for all shareholders, the requirement is in principle lacking. If individual family members remain subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany and continue to jointly control the structure, controlled foreign company taxation can apply.
What happens to an existing tax group if the controlling parent emigrates?
What matters is whether the participation in the subsidiary can still be attributed to a domestic permanent establishment of the controlling parent. If not, the tax group ends; if this falls below the five-year minimum term, it can lapse retroactively for the entire term of the agreement.
Should one obtain a binding ruling before a move with a family office structure?
The risks described depend heavily on the actual circumstances and can develop with case law. Particularly for larger assets, it is therefore advisable to apply for a binding ruling under Section 89 (2) AO before implementation and, where there is a foreign connection, to examine a corresponding possibility in the destination state.
Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala has published extensively on international company and tax law on emigration and supports clients in reviewing family office structures before a move abroad for exit tax, permanent establishment, controlled foreign company and tax group risks. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.