Transferring Shares to Family Before Emigrating from Germany: Opportunities and Limits

Transferring Shares to Family Before Emigrating from Germany: Opportunities and Limits

Transferring Shares to Family Before Emigrating

On fiala.de, the article Exit tax on GmbH shareholdings already explains the basic mechanics of exit taxation (Wegzugsbesteuerung) under Section 6 of the Foreign Tax Act (Außensteuergesetz, AStG) for the shareholder who keeps his or her shares. This article deals with the distinct case of transferring shares to family members before emigrating: what happens legally and for tax purposes when shares are transferred to a spouse, children or other family members before one’s own move, so that the person leaving no longer owns them when changing residence.

Anyone who owns shares in a GmbH and wants to move abroad hears sooner or later of an obvious idea: transfer the shares to the spouse or the children before the move, so that the person leaving no longer owns them and the exit tax under Section 6 AStG comes to nothing. As plausible as this thought sounds, implementing it is not simple. Transferring shares to family members before emigrating touches at least three areas of law at once: foreign tax law with its substitute provision (Ersatztatbestand), gift tax law with its own allowances and valuation rules, and the boundary of abusive structuring under Section 42 of the Fiscal Code (Abgabenordnung, AO). This article places these three levels in context.

Why Shareholders Transfer Their Shares Before Emigrating

The exit tax under Section 6 (1) AStG requires that a natural person holds shares within the meaning of Section 17 (1) sentence 1 of the Income Tax Act (Einkommensteuergesetz, EStG), that is, holds at least 1 percent of a corporation, and ends his or her unlimited tax liability in Germany by giving up residence or habitual abode. The law then assumes a fictitious sale at fair market value (gemeiner Wert), although nothing was sold and no money flows in. The hidden reserves accrued up to the day of departure thus become taxable immediately, which for valuable family businesses can quickly reach existential amounts. The basic mechanics, including valuation and payment arrangements, are explained in detail in the exit tax article linked above.

Section 6 AStG attaches to the holding of the person leaving, not to that of his or her family. If parents transfer their GmbH shares in good time and completely to a child who stays in Germany, the parents have no substantial holding of their own when they later leave, and the basic provision of Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 1 AStG no longer applies. In any case the exit tax only affects someone who, in the twelve years before the end of unlimited tax liability, was subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany for a total of at least seven years (Section 6 (2) AStG). The transfer itself, however, triggers its own legal consequences, which are often underestimated.

The 1 Percent Threshold and the Five-Year Look-Back

Whether a holding falls under Section 6 AStG is determined by Section 17 (1) sentence 1 EStG: it covers shares in which the taxpayer held at least 1 percent of the capital at any time within the last five years. In the case of a gift, Section 17 (1) sentence 4 EStG attributes the predecessor’s holding periods to the donee; the five-year look-back therefore does not start afresh for him or her. This affects the donee’s own future exit tax liability and also the acquisition costs: under Section 17 (2) sentence 5 EStG, for an acquisition free of charge the historical acquisition costs of the last predecessor who acquired for consideration remain decisive. The hidden reserves are therefore not “erased” by the transfer; they pass on to the family together with the shares.

The Substitute Provision: The Transfer Itself Can Trigger the Tax

The most important stumbling block lies in Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 AStG: this provision also treats the transfer free of charge to a person who is not subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany as a fictitious sale by the donor. A gift to a spouse or children therefore avoids the exit tax only if the donee is, and remains, subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany at the time of the transfer. If the children already live abroad, the tax arises for the donating parent at the time of the transfer (substitute provision). If the children move away only after the transfer, the substitute provision is not met, because their status at the time of the transfer is what counts; their later departure, however, triggers the exit tax for them if the requirements of Section 6 AStG are met in their case. Their plans to go abroad should therefore be examined in advance. Under civil law, the notarial form required by Section 15 (3) and (4) of the Limited Liability Companies Act (GmbHG) must also be observed for GmbH shares; only with an effective transfer in rem is the transaction complete.

Gift Tax Consequences of the Transfer

Anyone who avoids the exit tax by transferring does not swap it for tax exemption but for gift tax.

Allowances: Under Section 16 (1) of the Inheritance and Gift Tax Act (Erbschaftsteuer- und Schenkungsteuergesetz, ErbStG), the following allowances, among others, are available within ten years: 500,000 euros for spouses, 400,000 euros for each child, 200,000 euros for grandchildren. For valuable holdings these amounts are rarely sufficient; the excess value is subject to gift tax of 7 to 50 percent depending on the tax class and the amount acquired (tax class I: 7 to 30, II: 15 to 43, III: 30 to 50 percent; Section 19 (1) ErbStG). For this reason shares are often transferred in tranches over several years in order to use the allowances several times; where transfers go through intermediaries, it must also be examined whether there is a chain gift (Kettenschenkung) that the tax office will recognise. Details are in the article Chain gift and gift tax.

Valuation: For gift tax, Sections 11 and 12 ErbStG in conjunction with the Valuation Act (Bewertungsgesetz, BewG) require the same fair market value that would also be used for the exit tax: for unlisted GmbH shares the simplified earnings value method under Sections 199 et seq. BewG regularly applies, alternatively a business valuation report. This valuation therefore also continues to have effect for a later exit tax of the donee.

Relief for business assets: For family businesses, the following point often decides the actual burden: under Section 13b (1) no. 3 ErbStG, shares qualify for relief only if the donor directly held more than 25 percent of the nominal capital; without a pooling agreement with other shareholders, smaller holdings are even treated as administrative assets (Verwaltungsvermögen). If the requirements are met, 85 percent of the value is tax-exempt under Section 13a (1) ErbStG, and with an irrevocable option and an administrative assets ratio of no more than 20 percent even 100 percent (Section 13a (10) ErbStG), tied to a holding period of five or seven years respectively and a correspondingly higher minimum payroll total. If the holding is sold within the holding period or if the payroll or another post-tax rule is breached, the relief lapses retroactively in proportion. The mere departure of the donee is not a post-tax event (Section 13a (6) ErbStG). Two proceedings on inheritance tax law are pending before the Federal Constitutional Court (Bundesverfassungsgericht), in which oral hearings were held on 12 and 13 October 2026: 1 BvR 804/22 (relief for business assets, Sections 13a, 13b ErbStG) and 1 BvF 1/23 (valuation of real property, allowances and tax rates). A decision is still outstanding; the relief rules and the allowances may therefore change. For acquisitions that, together with other privileged acquisitions by the same person within ten years, exceed 26 million euros, Sections 13c and 28a ErbStG provide different rules up to a needs-based relief test (Verschonungsbedarfsprüfung); this mainly concerns very large family businesses and is not examined further here.

Example with entirely fictitious names and figures: Mr Albrecht holds 40 percent of his GmbH and passes 15 percentage points to his daughter two years before leaving. Because he held more than 25 percent before the transfer (Section 13b (1) no. 3 ErbStG), the transfer can remain 85 percent tax-exempt provided the payroll and holding rules are complied with and administrative assets are below 90 percent; for the rest, the daughter’s allowance of 400,000 euros counts. The remaining 25 percent continues to be subject to Section 6 AStG on the later departure. The example does not replace an examination of the individual case.

The Boundary of Abusive Structuring under Section 42 AO

Under Section 42 (2) AO, there is abuse where an inappropriate structure is chosen that, compared with an appropriate structure, leads to a tax advantage not provided for by law; the taxpayer can counter this with significant non-tax reasons. Transferring shares to family members is in principle a structure accepted by the legislature itself: the substitute provision in Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 AStG expressly regulates this case instead of prohibiting it. The close timing between the transfer and the departure therefore does not, on its own, constitute abusive structuring; what is decisive is always an overall assessment of the circumstances.

It becomes critical where the transfer is not economically serious, for instance where a retransfer was agreed from the outset or where the donor retains all the essential rights so that nothing changes economically. In such cases the tax authorities first examine whether beneficial ownership (wirtschaftliches Eigentum) has passed at all. Anyone who documents the transfer, carries it out for comprehensible family or business reasons and actually leaves shareholder rights to the donee stands on much safer legal ground than with a purely tax-motivated, short-term transfer inserted without a purpose of its own.

If Control Is to Stay in the Family: Voting Rights and Beneficial Ownership

Many business families want to transfer shares for tax reasons but not give up control immediately, and use usufruct, a voting proxy or a right of recall for this purpose. Here lies an important limit: according to the case law of the Federal Fiscal Court (Bundesfinanzhof), the passing of beneficial ownership of a GmbH share (Section 39 (2) no. 1 AO) requires that the acquirer obtains a position that can no longer be withdrawn against his or her will and that the essential rights as well as the opportunities and risks of value development accrue to him or her. According to lower-court case law, the voting right is a particularly weighty indicator. If the transferor in practice retains control through a voting proxy and a free right of revocation, beneficial ownership can remain with the transferor despite a civilly effective transfer, with the result that the shares could still be attributed to the transferor for the purposes of Section 6 AStG and the exit tax would specifically not be avoided.

Whether the reservation of usufruct or voting rights prevents the passing of beneficial ownership is a question of the individual case (Section 39 (2) no. 1 AO) and should be examined before implementation. A transfer with a reservation of voting rights should therefore not be carried out without prior legal review. Anyone who wants to keep control permanently without taking this risk should consider an interposed holding company, which the article Setting up a holding structure before emigrating examines in more depth.

Tax Group and Co-Entrepreneurship: Two Special Questions

If a corporate income tax group (Organschaft) exists between the company and another company, its recognition under Section 14 (1) sentence 1 no. 1 of the Corporate Income Tax Act (Körperschaftsteuergesetz, KStG) in principle requires the controlling entity (Organträger) to hold the majority of the voting rights in the subsidiary (Organgesellschaft); if the articles of association provide for qualified majorities, case law may even apply a higher threshold. If the transfer falls below the majority needed for financial integration, the continuation of the tax group is in question. The article Tax group when the controlling parent moves abroad explores this in more depth.

The position is different for holdings in partnerships such as a KG, OHG or GbR: Section 6 AStG refers exclusively to Section 17 EStG and covers only shares in corporations; the 1 percent threshold has no significance for co-entrepreneur interests (Mitunternehmeranteile). This does not mean that a move would be without consequences. Separate exit taxation rules (Entstrickungsregeln) take the place of the exit tax, in particular for special business assets, which the article Co-entrepreneurship and emigration explains.

Distinction from Other Structures and a Warning

Transferring to family members is only one of several responses to an impending exit tax. Alternatively, a sale of the shares before emigrating can be considered, which immediately triggers a capital gain under Section 17 EStG and can take the assets out of the family. A contribution to a family foundation is equally conceivable, an independent and complex structure that the article Family foundation for asset protection for emigrants puts in context. Finally, the burden can be spread through statutory payment in instalments under Section 6 (4) AStG without giving up the shares; the requirements are explained in the article Exit tax: payment in instalments over seven years.

On the internet there are also offers that combine a transfer of shares specifically with emigration to a country advertised as particularly tax-favourable. This article deliberately makes no statement on the choice of a destination country: that depends on personal and foreign legal factors that must be examined independently. Regardless of the destination country, the German rules described here on the substitute provision, gift tax and abusive structuring apply unchanged; blanket promises of complete tax avoidance should always be assessed against the law, not against advertising claims.

What Remains to Be Considered After the Move: The Return Rule

Anyone who, despite an earlier partial transfer, still retains a substantial holding of his or her own and later falls under Section 6 AStG should keep the return rule of Section 6 (3) AStG in mind if the stay abroad is meant to be only temporary. If the taxpayer becomes subject to unlimited tax liability again within seven years, the tax assessed can lapse on application, provided the remaining shares have not in the meantime been sold, transferred or contributed, no distributions of more than one quarter of the value at departure were made, and the German right to tax revives. On application the tax office can extend the period by up to five years. Anyone who has transferred only part of his or her shares must comply with this separately for the remaining part.

Practical Approach: Checklist Before the Transfer

← Tabelle nach links wischen, um weitere Spalten zu sehen

Step Content Points to note
1. Clarify the holding structure Record legal form, size of the holding, history of the last five years Basis for whether Section 6 AStG or different rules apply
2. Check the donee’s status Residence and planned stay in Germany Otherwise the substitute provision under Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 AStG threatens
3. Obtain a valuation Fair market value by simplified earnings value method or report Continues to have effect for a later exit tax of the donee
4. Calculate gift tax Allowances under Section 16 ErbStG, relief under Sections 13a, 13b ErbStG Observe the 25 percent minimum holding and holding periods
5. Clarify the control question Is voting right or usufruct to be retained? Risk that beneficial ownership stays with the transferor
6. Check side effects Tax group, pooling agreements, articles of association clauses Financial integration and relief may be linked
7. Plan documentation Record non-tax reasons for the transfer Protection against an abuse review under Section 42 AO
8. Consider a binding ruling Application under Section 89 (2) AO to the competent tax office Particularly useful for valuation or abuse questions
9. Notary appointment and shareholder list Notarial certification under Section 15 (3) and (4) GmbHG Only then is the transfer effective under civil law

The Binding Ruling as Protection

Valuation, relief and the question of abusive structuring depend heavily on the individual case, and the legal position on beneficial ownership where voting rights are retained has in part not yet been settled by the highest courts. For such cases the law provides its own instrument in the binding ruling (verbindliche Auskunft) under Section 89 (2) AO: for a fee measured by the value of the subject matter, the competent tax office can give a binding commitment on the assessment of a precisely defined set of facts that has not yet occurred. This creates legal certainty in advance that can hardly be established afterwards. The article Binding ruling before emigration explains the application, jurisdiction and costs. If the donee already lives abroad, it should also be examined whether the foreign tax authority offers a comparable ruling; that concerns foreign law and must be clarified with an adviser admitted there.

Conclusion

Transferring business shares to family members before one’s own departure can effectively avoid the exit tax under Section 6 AStG if the donee remains subject to unlimited tax liability in Germany and the transfer is properly completed under civil law. However, it does not replace the exit tax with tax exemption but with a separate gift tax liability with its own allowances, valuation rules and possible relief. Anyone who retains control through reservations of voting rights risks that beneficial ownership remains with the transferor and the tax effect is missed. Anyone who transfers solely in the short term and without a purpose of their own must expect a review under Section 42 AO. Early, documented planning, if in doubt secured by a binding ruling, is the difference between a viable structure and a later tax dispute.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does one automatically lose control of the company through the gift?

Under civil law, the shareholder rights, including the voting right, in principle pass with the shares. If an attempt is made to leave control with the transferor through a voting proxy or a reservation of usufruct, there is a risk that beneficial ownership has not passed completely at all.

What happens if the child who received the gift later moves abroad?

If the donee later meets the requirements of Section 6 AStG himself or herself, a separate exit tax can arise for the donee. If the donee was already no longer subject to unlimited tax liability at the time of the transfer, the substitute provision under Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 AStG hits the donor instead.

How is the value of the GmbH shares determined for gift tax?

The fair market value under the Valuation Act is decisive. For unlisted shares the simplified earnings value method under Sections 199 et seq. BewG regularly applies, alternatively a business valuation report.

Does the exit tax also apply to a holding in a KG, OHG or GbR?

No. Section 6 AStG refers to Section 17 EStG and covers only shares in corporations. For co-entrepreneur interests in partnerships, other, separate exit taxation rules apply on emigration.

Can the tax office treat the transfer as abusive structuring under Section 42 AO?

Under the general principles, the close timing to the departure alone is not sufficient; the legislature itself regulated the transfer free of charge in Section 6 (1) sentence 1 no. 2 AStG. It becomes critical if the transfer is not economically serious, for example where a retransfer was agreed from the outset.

What must be considered if a tax group is to continue after the transfer?

Financial integration under Section 14 KStG in principle requires the controlling entity to hold the majority of the voting rights, and in the case of qualified majorities in the articles of association possibly a higher threshold. If the holding falls below this because of the transfer, the continuation of the tax group is in question.

Attorney Dr. Johannes Fiala and the law firm, with a focus on international tax law, company law and asset protection in Munich, have published extensively on exit taxation and the preceding transfer of assets and shares, and advise clients on structuring share transfers before emigration, from gift tax planning through corporate law safeguards to the binding ruling. Get in touch with the firm without obligation to discuss your individual situation in an initial consultation.

Do you have questions?

Please do not hesitate to call us for an introductory conversation. I will gladly take the time personally to review your case and give you an estimate of the work involved.

That way, you will already be one step further!

You can reach us by phone at +49 89 / 17 90 900 or by clicking the button:

Call now
Portrait Dr. Fiala

Dr. Johannes Fiala

Your lawyer in Munich is reliable and competent, always by your side.

Recommend us

Found what you were looking for? Do you know someone who could use our support? Feel free to recommend us.